Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,155,533 members, 7,826,994 topics. Date: Tuesday, 14 May 2024 at 02:48 AM

Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters - Car Talk - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Car Talk / Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters (4021 Views)

Catalytic Converters Scraps / Sex In The Car And Its Consequences / Failing/clogged Catalytic Converters (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by cecegorz(m): 8:37am On Sep 15, 2016
I just had an experience with my car last week, and I thought to share for people to update their knowledge.
This experience cost me about a 100k only.

The car had never stalled in about 2 years since I bought it, only goes for regular maintenance services, so when I noticed it stalling on that Tuesday morning, I didn't hesitate to take it to the mechanic, amidst dying and restarting a couple of times along the way.

The mech first scanned the ECU and came up with codes about the catalysts, ignition coils and injection systems clogging, started by servicing the injection, changing coils and plug and yet no respite. So he lifted the car, went under and saw the whole exhaust system red hot as the engine was running, so he dismantled the whole stuff and discovered the 3 catalytic converters has been blocked, thus the engine couldn't breathe!
That was what put the whole system under pressure with collateral damages in the engine.

Consequently, engine got a cracked valve, bad gaskets and all.
Ultimately, the car spent 1 week in the shop and dug a 100k hole in my wallet.
I have uploaded the receipt of spare parts bought and replaced for mechanics in the house to review.

1 Like

Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by erico2k2(m): 11:16pm On Sep 15, 2016
your mechanic finish you nor B small,3 cat converters??
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by erico2k2(m): 11:19pm On Sep 15, 2016
cecegorz:
I just had an experience with my car last week, and I thought to share for people to update their knowledge.
This experience cost me about a 100k only.

The car had never stalled in about 2 years since I bought it, only goes for regular maintenance services, so when I noticed it stalling on that Tuesday morning, I didn't hesitate to take it to the mechanic, amidst dying and restarting a couple of times along the way.

The mech first scanned the ECU and came up with codes about the catalysts, ignition coils and injection systems clogging, started by servicing the injection, changing coils and plug and yet no respite. So he lifted the car, went under and saw the whole exhaust system red hot as the engine was running, so he dismantled the whole stuff and discovered the 3 catalytic converters has been blocked, thus the engine couldn't breathe!
That was what put the whole system under pressure with collateral damages in the engine.

Consequently, engine got a cracked valve, bad gaskets and all.
Ultimately, the car spent 1 week in the shop and dug a 100k hole in my wallet.
I have uploaded the receipt of spare parts bought and replaced for mechanics in the house to review.
The whole of ur Ignition coil can not go bad in one go plus there are simple test to check for that as well
Which of the gasket did you say was bad?
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by Emperoh(m): 3:08pm On Sep 16, 2016
cecegorz:
I just had an experience with my car last week, and I thought to share for people to update their knowledge.
This experience cost me about a 100k only.

The car had never stalled in about 2 years since I bought it, only goes for regular maintenance services, so when I noticed it stalling on that Tuesday morning, I didn't hesitate to take it to the mechanic, amidst dying and restarting a couple of times along the way.

The mech first scanned the ECU and came up with codes about the catalysts, ignition coils and injection systems clogging, started by servicing the injection, changing coils and plug and yet no respite. So he lifted the car, went under and saw the whole exhaust system red hot as the engine was running, so he dismantled the whole stuff and discovered the 3 catalytic converters has been blocked, thus the engine couldn't breathe!
That was what put the whole system under pressure with collateral damages in the engine.

Consequently, engine got a cracked valve, bad gaskets and all.
Ultimately, the car spent 1 week in the shop and dug a 100k hole in my wallet.
I have uploaded the receipt of spare parts bought and replaced for mechanics in the house to review.

This is a recurring issue for cars of late. I first experienced this in 2012 on a 2003 VW Passat. Car almost caught fire.
Then a colleagues 2001 Peugeot 406 and then another 2003 Camry.

I suspect it is the leaded fuel we use here. But I hope Siena and Gazzuz and Kingreign can come here and let's jawjaw on this.
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by cecegorz(m): 2:16pm On Sep 17, 2016
erico2k2:

The whole of ur Ignition coil can not go bad in one go plus there are simple test to check for that as well
Which of the gasket did you say was bad?

The coils were not changed finally.
I've been trying to upload the invoice, to show the changed items, but the size is over 6mb.
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by cecegorz(m): 2:18pm On Sep 17, 2016
Emperoh:


This is a recurring issue for cars of late. I first experienced this in 2012 on a 2003 VW Passat. Car almost caught fire.
Then a colleagues 2001 Peugeot 406 and then another 2003 Camry.

I suspect it is the leaded fuel we use here. But I hope Siena and Gazzuz and Kingreign can come here and let's jawjaw on this.

I wouldn't think our fuel is culpable, my other car has done over 5 years with me and the Cat never gave any sign of malfunction.
This particular one is still under 2 years, and I buy fuel from the same gas station all the time.
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by cecegorz(m): 2:56pm On Sep 17, 2016
Let me just write out the invoice of the total cost of parts and service charges, since I can't upload the pix:

1. Valve oil seal - 3,400
2. Valves - 12,000
3. Top gasket - 17,500
4. Engine oil - 5,600
5. oil filter - 1,500
6. Plugs (6) - 6,000
7. Surfacing of cylinder - 7,500
8. Sealant gum - 600
9. Valve cup - 1,000
10. Reconstruction of the 3 Cats by panel beater - 15,000
11. Workmanship - 25,000

Total cost - 100,000

P.S
The number 10 is based on what nisiparts nissparts explained as Alternative 2 in this thread https://www.nairaland.com/951734/explaining-catalysts-catalyst-codes
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by erico2k2(m): 3:07pm On Sep 17, 2016
cecegorz:
Let me just write out the invoice of the total cost of parts and service charges, since I can't upload the pix:

1. Valve oil seal - 3,400
2. Valves - 12,000
3. Top gasket - 17,500
4. Engine oil - 5,600
5. oil filter - 1,500
6. Plugs (6) - 6,000
7. Surfacing of cylinder - 7,500
8. Sealant gum - 600
9. Valve cup - 1,000
10. Reconstruction of the 3 Cats by panel beater - 15,000
11. Workmanship - 25,000

Total cost - 100,000

P.S
The number 10 is based on what nisiparts nissparts explained as Alternative 2 in this thread https://www.nairaland.com/951734/explaining-catalysts-catalyst-codes
you cannot re construct a cat converter, and howcome your car has three, what make and model?
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by cecegorz(m): 3:29pm On Sep 17, 2016
erico2k2:

you cannot re construct a cat converter, and howcome your car has three, what make and model?

Sorry, may be reconstruction is not the appropriate word.
What the panel beater did was cut open the canisters and remove the cats inside, then constructed some flat plates with multiple bores and placed them in stead of another cat. So effectively there's no more cats inside the canisters.

The car is Toyota Highlander.
One of the cats is closer to the engine, the 2nd one at the middle and the 3rd one close to the silencer.
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by boldx(m): 4:48pm On Sep 17, 2016
All that work on the exhaust for N15,000? Did you tell your mechanic you work in Shell BP?

2 Likes

Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by erico2k2(m): 4:51pm On Sep 17, 2016
cecegorz:


Sorry, may be reconstruction is not the appropriate word.
What the panel beater did was cut open the canisters and remove the cats inside, then constructed some flat plates with multiple bores and placed them in stead of another cat. So effectively there's no more cats inside the canisters.

The car is Toyota Highlander.
One of the cats is closer to the engine, the 2nd one at the middle and the 3rd one close to the silencer.
your car has Only two cat converter, not three, what he did there was just to milk you cos whatever he put in there has no meaning.The cat converters are made of special metals to convert harmful gases from ur Exhust system to friendly gas when they come out to the environment.these are the metals used in Cat converters
platinum, palladium and rhodium,.So at that he just did the more you look the less you see.
PLZ buy another cat converter for your car.

5 Likes

Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by Piyke: 5:38pm On Sep 17, 2016
cecegorz:
I just had an experience with my car last week, and I thought to share for people to update their knowledge.
This experience cost me about a 100k only.

The car had never stalled in about 2 years since I bought it, only goes for regular maintenance services, so when I noticed it stalling on that Tuesday morning, I didn't hesitate to take it to the mechanic, amidst dying and restarting a couple of times along the way.

The mech first scanned the ECU and came up with codes about the catalysts, ignition coils and injection systems clogging, started by servicing the injection, changing coils and plug and yet no respite. So he lifted the car, went under and saw the whole exhaust system red hot as the engine was running, so he dismantled the whole stuff and discovered the 3 catalytic converters has been blocked, thus the engine couldn't breathe!
That was what put the whole system under pressure with collateral damages in the engine.

Consequently, engine got a cracked valve, bad gaskets and all.
Ultimately, the car spent 1 week in the shop and dug a 100k hole in my wallet.
I have uploaded the receipt of spare parts bought and replaced for mechanics in the house to review.

Always better to address Cat issues when its just the codes; P0420/P0430. By the time you start having poor acceleration and difficulty ascending inclines, its an emergency. Did you not experience loss of power climbing hills before this? Cos from your post it gives the impression this happened without warning.

1 Like

Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by cecegorz(m): 5:44pm On Sep 17, 2016
erico2k2:

your car has Only two cat converter, not three, what he did there was just to milk you cos whatever he put in there has no meaning.The cat converters are made of special metals to convert harmful gases from ur Exhust system to friendly gas when they come out to the environment.these are the metals used in Cat converters
platinum, palladium and rhodium,.So at that he just did the more you look the less you see.
PLZ buy another cat converter for your car.

No way I'm buying a new cat in this economy. A quick Google gives costs at approx $1500, with delivery is like 700k.

Second option is the Tokunbo version from Ladipo, which shelf life you Can't determine, as it may also fail within the shortest possible time.

Until there's another reasonable alternative, I'm OK as it is.
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by erico2k2(m): 5:47pm On Sep 17, 2016
cecegorz:


No way I'm buying a new cat in this economy. A quick Google gives costs at approx $1500, with delivery is like 700k.

Second option is the Tokunbo version from Ladipo, which shelf life you Can't determine, as it may also fail within the shortest possible time.

Until there's another reasonable alternative, I'm OK as it is.
ok noted
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by cecegorz(m): 5:47pm On Sep 17, 2016
Piyke:


Always better to address Cat issues when its just the codes; P0420/P0430. By the time you start having poor acceleration and difficulty ascending inclines, its an emergency. Did you not experience loss of power climbing hills before this? Cos from your post it gives the impression this happened without warning.

You're absolutely right.
Never had any warning prior to that day. It would have easy if I had noticed when it was just the cats, before it tore my other components apart
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by chukel(m): 2:56pm On Sep 18, 2016
cecegorz:


You're absolutely right.
Never had any warning prior to that day. It would have easy if I had noticed when it was just the cats, before it tore my other components apart
but Bro, u had check light for a long time. Just cos the car was moving well, u ignored it. It pays to have a scanner. U would have taken action a long time ago before spilling 100k. Contact me for ur car scanner.
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by cecegorz(m): 3:14pm On Sep 18, 2016
chukel:
but Bro, u had check light for a long time. Just cos the car was moving well, u ignored it. It pays to have a scanner. U would have taken action a long time ago before spilling 100k. Contact me for ur car scanner.

I'll tell you how I entered this 'one-chance'.

I had a previous unrelated issue that prompted the CEL, but after resolving the issue, the CEL was not cleared. I took it back to the Mech and he cleared it but surprisingly it returned, I just ignored it, waiting for the next maintenance run so he can clear it again.
I think that clearing the CEL after fixing faults can be challenging a times? No?

Can you post the pix of your scanner and the price?
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by prdeal: 11:55pm On Apr 10, 2018
You can check out https://pgmrecoverysystems.com/where-to-recycle-catalytic-converter/ is the best place to recycle catalytic converters
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by NeyofeedNigEnt: 11:13pm On Apr 11, 2018
chukel:
but Bro, u had check light for a long time. Just cos the car was moving well, u ignored it. It pays to have a scanner. U would have taken action a long time ago before spilling 100k. Contact me for ur car scanner.

How much is your scanner please
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by chukel(m): 5:51am On Apr 12, 2018
NeyofeedNigEnt:


How much is your scanner please
20k
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by NeyofeedNigEnt: 8:47am On Apr 12, 2018
chukel:
20k

I'm in Ibadan and how can I get one
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by chukel(m): 7:57pm On Apr 12, 2018
NeyofeedNigEnt:


I'm in Ibadan and how can I get one
I will courier to you after payment.
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by NeyofeedNigEnt: 11:29pm On Apr 12, 2018
chukel:
I will courier to you after payment.

OK. Let's chat privately. WhatsApp me 08058286101
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by Uteghe(m): 2:30pm On Aug 20, 2019
Had same experience with my car.
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by Edunwa302(m): 6:51pm On Aug 20, 2019
Piyke:


Always better to address Cat issues when its just the codes; P0420/P0430. By the time you start having poor acceleration and difficulty ascending inclines, its an emergency. Did you not experience loss of power climbing hills before this? Cos from your post it gives the impression this happened without warning.
I'm curently having excert issues on my 08 camry 4 cylinder no code can you help
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by Edunwa302(m): 6:52pm On Aug 20, 2019
Edunwa302:

I'm curently having excert issues on my 08 camry 4 cylinder no code can you help
I mean the symptoms you mentioned
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by Piyke: 9:43pm On Aug 20, 2019
Edunwa302:

I mean the symptoms you mentioned

Does the car smoke? Can you confirm you check engine light bulb was not removed?
Re: Consequences Of Failed Catalytic Converters by Edunwa302(m): 8:45am On Aug 21, 2019
Piyke:


Does the car smoke? Can you confirm you check engine light bulb was not removed?
The car doesn't smoke or consume oil
The check bulb is still there last month i had p0303 code and p0103 code which i cleared with my OBD11 scanner after change new plugs..... So the bulb is still there and working
The car is just 5months in nigeria .
Thanks for your response so far

(1) (Reply)

My Car Drags And Makes A High Sound Before Gear Selection / Is The Landrover Free Lander A Good Car / What Was Your First Car?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 61
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.