Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,156,161 members, 7,829,145 topics. Date: Wednesday, 15 May 2024 at 08:21 PM

Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' - Foreign Affairs - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Foreign Affairs / Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' (737 Views)

War In Ukraine: 'America Is Learning The Art Of Humility' / Jens Stoltenberg: Russia Is Using Cluster Bombs In Ukraine / RUSSIA Is Set To Begin Final Tests On Its Lethal Hypersonic 6100mph Missile(Pix) (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by olugabbie(m): 4:42am On Feb 01, 2023
Source-bbc.com

Ukrainian troops on the front lines in the Donbas have told the BBC that Russian forces are "learning every day and changing their strategy" as they continue to gain ground around the heavily contested town of Bakhmut. But the soldiers also insisted that morale remains high, despite growing exhaustion after almost a year of war.

The two Ukrainian soldiers swept into the room, still visibly flushed with adrenalin, having just driven straight from the furiously active front lines along the rolling, snow-covered hills further south. Peering over a giant map at their brigade's temporary headquarters, they jabbed at the spots where Russian forces were inching forwards towards a key road.

"They were about 400 metres [437 yards] from us, across the field just here. We're holding on, but it's getting harder," said Sgt Denys Kalchuk from the all-volunteer Dnipro-1 Battalion, going on to describe how Russian infantry, fighter jets and artillery units appeared to be operating with growing co-ordination and effectiveness around Bakhmut.

"The planes are the worst. You can't hear them until it's too late. It's the same with the tanks. Artillery is easier - at least you might have a second or two [to dive for cover] after you hear them coming," said Sgt Kalchuk.

Assessing the overall state of the conflict across the Donbas is extremely difficult. Access is challenging and dangerous, and dozens of different Ukrainian battalions and brigades are working on separate tasks, amid some secrecy, spread out along hundreds of miles of often fast-changing front lines.

But after several weeks travelling across the region, and more than a dozen on-the-record interviews and frank off-the-record discussions with a broad range of Ukrainian soldiers, I have seen various themes emerging.

For weeks, Russia's notorious mercenary group Wagner has led much of the fighting around Bakhmut, sustaining catastrophic numbers of casualties by launching near-suicidal mass infantry attacks on smaller towns like Soledar. But in recent days, according to some Ukrainian soldiers, Russia's regular army has resumed a more prominent role, with noticeable effect.

"It is very hard for us now. We understand that Russia is learning every day and changing their strategy. And I think we need to learn faster," said Dmytro Podvorchanskyi, who heads a reconnaissance unit in Dnipro-1.

He and others spoke of the way well-equipped regular Russian forces were now hiding and dispersing their ammunition stores far better and targeting Ukrainian logistics routes more effectively. As a result, they are continuing to gain ground around Bakhmut and threatening another potentially significant town, Vuhledar, further south.

But there is no indication, as yet, that Russian forces are poised to make a strategically significant breakthrough. One senior commander said Western supplies had now brought a balance to what had been a deeply uneven artillery war, and that Western tanks could soon tip the overall balance in Ukraine's favour.

While it is no surprise that many Ukrainian troops are suffering from exhaustion after months of conflict, morale, in general, appears to be holding.

"There have been cases of [Ukrainian] units who don't seem willing to fight, and disagreements [over tactics]," one Ukrainian soldier acknowledged, speaking off the record.

Others talked about the trauma of seeing their friends die, of units that had sustained overwhelming numbers of casualties and of the psychological impact of fighting amidst the corpses of so many uncollected Russian soldiers. One soldier, citing fears of a new Russian mobilisation and the huge size of the enemy's population, spoke of his fear that "Russia will grind us down". But most troops we met waved away such doubts, blaming them on exhaustion and - in general - praising their commanders for giving them time to rest.

One increasingly common excuse offered for Ukraine's struggles around Bakhmut is the theory that relatively weak and inexperienced units are now being left to hold the line here, while the army's strongest forces are being moved elsewhere ahead of a widely anticipated Ukrainian counterattack, or counterattacks.

The location of any such potential offensives remains the subject of much speculation among Ukrainian troops. Some anticipate a push further north, into Luhansk province, while others wonder about an attack south towards Melitopol, in order to isolate and threaten Russian forces in and around the Crimean peninsula.

One experienced officer said he believed Russia was looking to straighten its frontline, take a few more chunks of the Donbas, and then declare "mission accomplished" and push for peace negotiations. He said he was sure Ukraine would never agree to that but warned that the military would need Western fighter jets to break through all of Russia's new defences, particularly in the south of the country.

1 Share

Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by olugabbie(m): 4:43am On Feb 01, 2023
Before you block me. Please verify on BBC website.
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Nobody: 5:37am On Feb 01, 2023
A good political analysts will always read between the lines of western news reports. You can see there is a lot of copium in this BBC report. It initially describes what is happening, which is that Russians are gaining grounds nd improving, then it began to add some bits which are just irreverent. This is how western reports give false hopes. They know what they are doing. Backmut is doomed irrespective.

10 Likes

Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by olugabbie(m): 8:03am On Feb 01, 2023
atmy1:
A good political analysts will always read between the lines of western news reports. You can see there is a lot of copium in this BBC report. It initially describes what is happening, which is that Russians are gaining grounds nd improving, then it began to add some bits which are just irreverent. This is how western reports give false hopes. They know what they are doing. Backmut is doomed irrespective.



Yea
They only talk about Russia casualties. Russia has more artillery than Ukraine. So it is expected that Ukrainian casualties will be higher. Artillery pieces kill more soldiers in this war than any other weapon.

4 Likes 1 Share

Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by seunny4lif(m): 2:23pm On Feb 01, 2023
atmy1:
A good political analysts will always read between the lines of western news reports. You can see there is a lot of copium in this BBC report. It initially describes what is happening, which is that Russians are gaining grounds nd improving, then it began to add some bits which are just irreverent. This is how western reports give false hopes. They know what they are doing. Backmut is doomed irrespective.
Even Ukraine former minister that resigned few days ago said the same thing.
He said if Ukraine don’t mobilise troops within 2 weeks they will lose everything.

Ukraine troops dead should be around 200K because if EU President can said Ukraine have lost over 100K 3 months ago and Croatia President said Ukraine have lost over 150K troops then it’s obvious.
The first 3 months of the war, Russia lost heavy but since they changed to using Syria campaign methods of burn everything to ground before moving, they have made it hard for Ukraine troops.
Many foreign fighters fighting for Ukraine that got out alive blamed Ukraine government for lying about the frontline

5 Likes 1 Share

Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by bassdow: 2:38pm On Feb 01, 2023
seunny4lif:

Even Ukraine former minister that resigned few days ago said the same thing.
He said if Ukraine don’t mobilise troops within 2 weeks they will lose everything.

Ukraine troops dead should be around 200K because if EU President can said Ukraine have lost over 100K 3 months ago and Croatia President said Ukraine have lost over 150K troops then it’s obvious.
The first 3 months of the war, Russia lost heavy but since they changed to using Syria campaign methods of burn everything to ground before moving, they have made it hard for Ukraine troops.
Many foreign fighters fighting for Ukraine that got out alive blamed Ukraine government for lying about the frontline

I know it's difficult for One to willingly agree to Loose a Territory, but in this Ukraine situation, it's more like when a (forex) Trader tries to get back at the market - you go loose more, if not all. While trying to resist Russia, they Permanently lost Four regions, there are signs they might permanently loose more regions. This is for conflict wey Russia no initially even come take anything.
It's getting much worse now that even NATO and Eu is finding it difficult recruiting more soldiers to as mercenaries.

Na Wa Ooo. Just 1 country doing all these, and our cow3 still dey commission borehole water wey go stop working few months later

3 Likes

Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by seunny4lif(m): 2:50pm On Feb 01, 2023
bassdow:


I know it's difficult for One to willingly agree to Loose a Territory, but in this Ukraine situation, it's more like when a (forex) Trader tries to get back at the market - you go loose more, if not all. While trying to resist Russia, they Permanently lost Four regions, there are signs they might permanently loose more regions. This is for conflict wey Russia no initially even come take anything.
It's getting much worse now that even NATO and Eu is finding it difficult recruiting more soldiers to as mercenaries.

Na Wa Ooo. Just 1 country doing all these, and our cow3 still dey commission borehole water wey go stop working few months later
Nigeria don’t even have troops because our military men and women have been turned to political police.
Nigeria military officers are now being used to protect politicians and their families, imagine someone like MC Olumo having military men protecting him
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Vl3ly: 3:46pm On Feb 01, 2023
seunny4lif:

Even Ukraine former minister that resigned few days ago said the same thing.
He said if Ukraine don’t mobilise troops within 2 weeks they will lose everything.

Ukraine troops dead should be around 200K because if EU President can said Ukraine have lost over 100K 3 months ago and Croatia President said Ukraine have lost over 150K troops then it’s obvious.
The first 3 months of the war, Russia lost heavy but since they changed to using Syria campaign methods of burn everything to ground before moving, they have made it hard for Ukraine troops.
Many foreign fighters fighting for Ukraine that got out alive blamed Ukraine government for lying about the frontline
200k ke, ukraine are in 8th round of mobilization now, where are there main soldiers talkless of 1st to 7th mobilized forces
There casualties would be btw 300k to 400k

5 Likes 1 Share

Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Nobody: 4:08pm On Feb 01, 2023
Vl3ly:
200k ke, ukraine are in 8th round of mobilization now, where are there main soldiers talkless of 1st to 7th mobilized forces
There casualties would be btw 300k to 400k


In Backmut alone, they are losing hundreds daily and this has been going on for the past 3 months. When they finally declassify this war's documents, The Ukrainians will ask, is it worth it?
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by seunny4lif(m): 4:12pm On Feb 01, 2023
Vl3ly:
200k ke, ukraine are in 8th round of mobilization now, where are there main soldiers talkless of 1st to 7th mobilized forces
There casualties would be btw 300k to 400k
Let just agree on 200K.
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Vl3ly: 5:14pm On Feb 01, 2023
seunny4lif:

Let just agree on 200K.
agreed

Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Siwisheswereesh: 9:02pm On Feb 01, 2023
All hail pro-Putin luuunatics!!!

The war will soon be one year old and Russia is nowhere near achieving its objectives in Ukraine.

The war in the Donbas region is tough because of the well grounded separatists there.
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by olugabbie(m): 1:48am On Feb 02, 2023
Siwisheswereesh:
All hail pro-Putin luuunatics!!!

The war will soon be one year old and Russia is nowhere near achieving its objectives in Ukraine.

The war in the Donbas region is tough because of the well grounded separatists there.

The West is the life line of Ukraine. They have been trying to keep Ukraine in the fight.

The Ukrainian counter offensive was a failure. In Kharkov, they fought against very few Russian troops. Russia did not have enough troops to protect both flanks at the same time. So they made the decision to protect Kherson (in the south). They move soldiers from Kharkov to Kherson and Kharkov became vulnerable. This decision gave the Ukrainians the opportunity to seize Kharkov. Ukraine took Kharkov under heavy artillery fire and they lost a lots of soldiers. Russian troops were able to retreat with minimum loses. Immediately the Ukrainians got to Lugansk border, where there were substantial Russian troops they counter offensive stall.

In Kherson, at first Ukraine launch a huge counter offensive in an open terrain. Russian forces retreated and bombarded them with artillery. The Ukrainians lost a lots of soldiers and immediately stopped the huge counter offensive. The later settled for using reconnaissance group to probe Russian defenses. Each time they tried, they loose huge number of the probing forces. If you remember, when Russia said it will withdraw it troops. They Ukrainians said it was a trap. This is because of the experience they hard. Russia was waiting for Ukraine to engage but they never did. They were scared of loosing more soldiers. But when Russia could not sustain it logistics in the Region and Ukraine was not willing to attack. They pull out all their forces with almost zero casualties. This was achieved by Sorovikin (aka Gen Armageddon). Ukraine is no match for Russia. The counter offensive brought more death to the Ukrainians than never before. They took 50% of Kherson. But they could not occupy it, because of Russian artillery. Kharkov will be taken back by Russia definitely.

Now Ukraine has lost the capacity to carry out any major counter offensive. They are waiting their people that are being in NATO countries. They intend to use them in a major counter offensive.
Russia is de-militarising Ukraine by killing it soldiers in large number and destroying it equipments. This explain the reason why Ukraine has gone through several mobilization. While Russia has just done one. Taking the whole country will not profit Russia.. it will be hard for Russia to maintain it. The West will turn the Ukrainians to insurgents like they did in Afghanistan. Russia is interested in taking the East (Donbas, Zaprophizia), South (Kherson), North (Kharkov) and may be Odessa. Then probably turn the other part to Afghanistan.

3 Likes 1 Share

Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Siwisheswereesh: 9:28am On Feb 02, 2023
olugabbie:


The West is the life line of Ukraine. They have been trying to keep Ukraine in the fight.

The Ukrainian counter offensive was a failure. In Kharkov, they fought against very few Russian troops. Russia did not have enough troops to protect both flanks at the same time. So they made the decision to protect Kherson (in the south). They move soldiers from Kharkov to Kherson and Kharkov became vulnerable. This decision gave the Ukrainians the opportunity to seize Kharkov. Ukraine took Kharkov under heavy artillery fire and they lost a lots of soldiers. Russian troops were able to retreat with minimum loses. Immediately the Ukrainians got to Lugansk border, where there were substantial Russian troops they counter offensive stall.

In Kherson, at first Ukraine launch a huge counter offensive in an open terrain. Russian forces retreated and bombarded them with artillery. The Ukrainians lost a lots of soldiers and immediately stopped the huge counter offensive. The later settled for using reconnaissance group to probe Russian defenses. Each time they tried, they loose huge number of the probing forces. If you remember, when Russia said it will withdraw it troops. They Ukrainians said it was a trap. This is because of the experience they hard. Russia was waiting for Ukraine to engage but they never did. They were scared of loosing more soldiers. But when Russia could not sustain it logistics in the Region and Ukraine was not willing to attack. They pull out all their forces with almost zero casualties. This was achieved by Sorovikin (aka Gen Armageddon). Ukraine is no match for Russia. The counter offensive brought more death to the Ukrainians than never before. They took 50% of Kherson. But they could not occupy it, because of Russian artillery. Kharkov will be taken back by Russia definitely.

Now Ukraine has lost the capacity to carry out any major counter offensive. They are waiting their people that are being in NATO countries. They intend to use them in a major counter offensive.
Russia is de-militarising Ukraine by killing it soldiers in large number and destroying it equipments. This explain the reason why Ukraine has gone through several mobilization. While Russia has just done one. Taking the whole country will not profit Russia.. it will be hard for Russia to maintain it. The West will turn the Ukrainians to insurgents like they did in Afghanistan. Russia is interested in taking the East (Donbas, Zaprophizia), South (Kherson), North (Kharkov) and may be Odessa. Then probably turn the other part to Afghanistan.

Load of hogwash!!! angry

Russia have sustained far more casualties in this was than Ukraine. But because they have a far huger population, they will not feel their losses like Ukraine would. embarassed

Go and read CBS news and see how Russians are dying in numbers. Even the Ukrainian are wondering how the Russians can be so suicidal. It's a bloodbath. Ukraine would rather withdraw from a battle than suffer heavy losses. And they always say it whenever they do.

My point is that Putin NEVER anticipated that the war will be this long and he has since adjusted his goals to liberating the Donbas following realities on ground.

However, Ukraine don't want to give up the Donbas easily. They believe doing so will allow Russia to ask for more sooner or later. embarassed
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Nobody: 10:20am On Feb 02, 2023
Siwisheswereesh:


Load of hogwash!!! angry

Russia have sustained far more casualties in this was than Ukraine. But because they have a far huger population, they will not feel their losses like Ukraine would. embarassed

Go and read CBS news and see how Russians are dying in numbers. Even the Ukrainian are wondering how the Russians can be so suicidal. It's a bloodbath. Ukraine would rather withdraw from a battle than suffer heavy losses. And they always say it whenever they do.

My point is that Putin NEVER anticipated that the war will be this long and he has since adjusted his goals to liberating the Donbas following realities on ground.

A new BBC report puts Russia's casualties at over 20,000 wheereas even the EU leader Ms Von De Lying mistakenly revealed last year that over 100,000 Ukrainian troops have died. It is normal for the west to downplay Ukraine's losses and exxergerate Russia's losses but even western leaders are showing serious concerns with Ukraine's astronomical losses. This means something is terribly wrong. You can keep coping in your beliefs because you hate Russia and the western media feeds your indulgence like drug but reality is there.

However, Ukraine don't want to give up the Donbas easily. They believe doing so will allow Russia to ask for more sooner or later. embarassed
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by olugabbie(m): 11:32am On Feb 02, 2023
Siwisheswereesh:


Load of hogwash!!! angry

Russia have sustained far more casualties in this was than Ukraine. But because they have a far huger population, they will not feel their losses like Ukraine would. embarassed

Go and read CBS news and see how Russians are dying in numbers. Even the Ukrainian are wondering how the Russians can be so suicidal. It's a bloodbath. Ukraine would rather withdraw from a battle than suffer heavy losses. And they always say it whenever they do.

My point is that Putin NEVER anticipated that the war will be this long and he has since adjusted his goals to liberating the Donbas following realities on ground.

However, Ukraine don't want to give up the Donbas easily. They believe doing so will allow Russia to ask for more sooner or later. embarassed

Lol

How many soldiers did Russia lost in Kherson during Ukrainian counter offensive?
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Segun2222: 1:44pm On Feb 19, 2023
olugabbie:


The West is the life line of Ukraine. They have been trying to keep Ukraine in the fight.

The Ukrainian counter offensive was a failure. In Kharkov, they fought against very few Russian troops. Russia did not have enough troops to protect both flanks at the same time. So they made the decision to protect Kherson (in the south). They move soldiers from Kharkov to Kherson and Kharkov became vulnerable. This decision gave the Ukrainians the opportunity to seize Kharkov. Ukraine took Kharkov under heavy artillery fire and they lost a lots of soldiers. Russian troops were able to retreat with minimum loses. Immediately the Ukrainians got to Lugansk border, where there were substantial Russian troops they counter offensive stall.

In Kherson, at first Ukraine launch a huge counter offensive in an open terrain. Russian forces retreated and bombarded them with artillery. The Ukrainians lost a lots of soldiers and immediately stopped the huge counter offensive. The later settled for using reconnaissance group to probe Russian defenses. Each time they tried, they loose huge number of the probing forces. If you remember, when Russia said it will withdraw it troops. They Ukrainians said it was a trap. This is because of the experience they hard. Russia was waiting for Ukraine to engage but they never did. They were scared of loosing more soldiers. But when Russia could not sustain it logistics in the Region and Ukraine was not willing to attack. They pull out all their forces with almost zero casualties. This was achieved by Sorovikin (aka Gen Armageddon). Ukraine is no match for Russia. The counter offensive brought more death to the Ukrainians than never before. They took 50% of Kherson. But they could not occupy it, because of Russian artillery. Kharkov will be taken back by Russia definitely.

Now Ukraine has lost the capacity to carry out any major counter offensive. They are waiting their people that are being in NATO countries. They intend to use them in a major counter offensive.
Russia is de-militarising Ukraine by killing it soldiers in large number and destroying it equipments. This explain the reason why Ukraine has gone through several mobilization. While Russia has just done one. Taking the whole country will not profit Russia.. it will be hard for Russia to maintain it. The West will turn the Ukrainians to insurgents like they did in Afghanistan. Russia is interested in taking the East (Donbas, Zaprophizia), South (Kherson), North (Kharkov) and may be Odessa. Then probably turn the other part to Afghanistan.
Russia has done one mobilization grin
Re: Russia Is Learning - We Need To Learn Faster' by Segun2222: 1:46pm On Feb 19, 2023
olugabbie:


The West is the life line of Ukraine. They have been trying to keep Ukraine in the fight.

The Ukrainian counter offensive was a failure. In Kharkov, they fought against very few Russian troops. Russia did not have enough troops to protect both flanks at the same time. So they made the decision to protect Kherson (in the south). They move soldiers from Kharkov to Kherson and Kharkov became vulnerable. This decision gave the Ukrainians the opportunity to seize Kharkov. Ukraine took Kharkov under heavy artillery fire and they lost a lots of soldiers. Russian troops were able to retreat with minimum loses. Immediately the Ukrainians got to Lugansk border, where there were substantial Russian troops they counter offensive stall.

In Kherson, at first Ukraine launch a huge counter offensive in an open terrain. Russian forces retreated and bombarded them with artillery. The Ukrainians lost a lots of soldiers and immediately stopped the huge counter offensive. The later settled for using reconnaissance group to probe Russian defenses. Each time they tried, they loose huge number of the probing forces. If you remember, when Russia said it will withdraw it troops. They Ukrainians said it was a trap. This is because of the experience they hard. Russia was waiting for Ukraine to engage but they never did. They were scared of loosing more soldiers. But when Russia could not sustain it logistics in the Region and Ukraine was not willing to attack. They pull out all their forces with almost zero casualties. This was achieved by Sorovikin (aka Gen Armageddon). Ukraine is no match for Russia. The counter offensive brought more death to the Ukrainians than never before. They took 50% of Kherson. But they could not occupy it, because of Russian artillery. Kharkov will be taken back by Russia definitely.

Now Ukraine has lost the capacity to carry out any major counter offensive. They are waiting their people that are being in NATO countries. They intend to use them in a major counter offensive.
Russia is de-militarising Ukraine by killing it soldiers in large number and destroying it equipments. This explain the reason why Ukraine has gone through several mobilization. While Russia has just done one. Taking the whole country will not profit Russia.. it will be hard for Russia to maintain it. The West will turn the Ukrainians to insurgents like they did in Afghanistan. Russia is interested in taking the East (Donbas, Zaprophizia), South (Kherson), North (Kharkov) and may be Odessa. Then probably turn the other part to Afghanistan.
whats all this mansplaining because russia lost some battles you no believe yhay russia can loose battles grin

(1) (Reply)

How The ICC Warrant Successfully Isolates Russia? / Pakinstan Gets New President! / Re: I'm African But Find It Difficult To Love Obama

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 89
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.