SIRTee15:

I've updated. Check the response answer. Your answer is there.

Nothing is there.

https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/3847-burnt-offering#anchor12

SIRTee15:


I need glasses. Very good one.

This is because "scent molecules"

Ask chatgpt does smoke have an aroma/smell?

Maynman:

Nothing is there.

https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/3847-burnt-offering#anchor12

I updated. God is not interested in the smoke but the aroma.

This is from the link evidence u produced
Olah means that which go up.
Jephthah presented his daughter unto the Lord. Not burnt her as sacrifice.

SIRTee15:


I updated. God is not interested in the smoke but the aroma.

This is from the link evidence u produced
Olah means that which go up.
Jephthah presented his daughter unto the Lord. Not burnt her as sacrifice.

The name is a translation of the Septuagint rendering, which is itself based upon the descriptive phrase often attached to "'olah" in the ritual prescriptions: "an offering made by fire unto the Lord" lol

Maynman:


The name is a translation of the Septuagint rendering, which is itself based upon the descriptive phrase often attached to "'olah" in the ritual prescriptions: "an offering made by fire unto the Lord" lol

I'm talking about the original Hebrew meaning. Olah literally means to bring up.
The Septuagint is the one that attached olah with burnt offering. Pls read about Septuagint b4 replying.

Maynman:

This is because "scent molecules"

Ask chatgpt does smoke have an aroma/smell?

Ask it yourself.
What's diffusion? Tell me what u learnt about diffusion in chemistry class.

SIRTee15:


I'm talking about the original Hebrew meaning. Olah literally means to bring up.
The Septuagint is the one that attached olah with burnt offering. Pls read about Septuagint b4 replying.

Olay means to ascend, the smoke which is ascending.
The septuagint is not written in hebrew but greek, olah is just one of the korbans.
Jepthat or whatever sacrifice his child just like moab did.

SIRTee15:

Ask it yourself.
What's diffusion? Tell me what u learnt about diffusion in chemistry class.

Aroma doesn't diffuse, it is particles that diffuse.
Burning smoke ALWAYS go up

Maynman:

Olay means to ascend, the smoke which is ascending.
The septuagint is not written in hebrew but greek, olah is just one of the korbans.
Jepthat or whatever sacrifice his child just like moab did.

What u posted validate my point.
The root meaning of olah is 'to ascend'. It doesn't say anything about smoke ascending...stop lying.
It could be used for burnt offering but also be used as 'to go up' or 'offer to something higher'
Septuagint attached it permanently to burnt offering. They are not wrong but olah could mean other things in the literal sense.

Maynman:

Aroma doesn't diffuse, it is particles that diffuse.
Burning smoke ALWAYS go up

Do smoke diffuse?

SIRTee15:


What u posted validate my point.
The root meaning of olah is 'to ascend'. It doesn't say anything about smoke ascending...stop lying.
It could be used for burnt offering but also be used as 'to go up' or 'offer to something higher'
Septuagint attached it permanently to burnt offering. They are not wrong but olah could mean other things.

The thing that is ascending is smoke from burning, olah ALWAYS mean burnt sacrifice and in this type, all of the animal part is sacrificed.
You "offer" the burnt sacrifice to the lord through the smoke that goes up lol.

SIRTee15:


Do smoke diffuse?

Burning Smoke goes up always.

Does smoke have an aroma?

Maynman:


Burning Smoke goes up always.

Does smoke have an aroma?

That's not my question.

Do smoke diffuse. Yes or No.

SIRTee15:


That's not my question.

Do smoke diffuse. Yes or No.

Listen to your advice and answer the question I have been asking you.

Does smoke have an aroma? Yes or No

[quote author=Maynman post=125558956]

Listen to your advice and answer the question I have been asking you.

Does smoke have an aroma? Yes or No [/quote

I asked u first but u dodged a simple question. Yes smoke and aroma do diffuse. So both spread out from it's original source.

Now answer this question. Do u need a smoke for there to be aroma.

[quote author=SIRTee15 post=125559065][/quote]

Lol, you didn't answer the question.
Does smoke have aroma. Yes or No.

All smoke has smell, it doesn't need diffusion from aroma, wtf is that gan lol

When you burn something, won't the smell of that thing come out in the smoke?

Maynman:


Lol, you didn't answer the question.
Does smoke have aroma. Yes or No.

All smoke has smell, it doesn't need diffusion from aroma, wtf is that gan lol

When you burn something, won't the smell of that thing come out in the smoke?

Where did I say smoke needs diffusion from aroma?
Go and find your chemistry textbook and read about diffusion.

Now answer my question. Must there be smoke to have aroma?
Do u need smoke to produce aroma?

SIRTee15:


Where did I say smoke eeds diffusion from aroma?
Go and find your chemistry textbook and read about diffusion.

Now answer my .. Must here be smoke to have aroma?
Do u need smoke t
o produce aroma?

What do you mean by smoke AND aroma diffuse and spread out?
Smoke is not an object, everything that makes up the smoke, the smell is part of the smoke, it's chemicals acting up.

SIRTee15:


Now answer my question. Must there be smoke to have aroma?
Do u need smoke
to produce aroma?

You generate smoke through burning, I already told you don't need to cook to get aroma, but when you cook only steam and smoke GOES UP LITERALLY. You will see it go up.

Maynman:

You generate smoke through burning, I already told you don't need to cook to get aroma, but when you cook only steam and smoke GOES UP LITERALLY. You will see it go up.

So u can have aroma without smoke.
You don't need smoke or burnt offering to have aroma/sweet smelling savour.
Olah means to ascend.

Jephthah offered her daughter's chastity which is to ascend as an aroma unto God.
There was no burnt sacrifice.

SIRTee15:


So u can have aroma without smoke.
You don't need smoke or burnt offering to have aroma/sweet smelling savour.
Olah means to ascend.

Jephthah offered her daughter's chastity which is to ascend as an aroma unto God.
There was no burnt sacrifice.

Yes, your poo smells without burning it.
Olah means to ascend and the ascension is smoke that is going up.

Jepthat or whatever killed his daughter like moab did too.
The talmud and midrash further supports this clear thing

Maynman:

Yes, your poo smells without burning it.
Olah means to ascend and the ascension is smoke that is going up.

Jepthat or whatever killed his daughter like moab did too.
The talmud and midrash further supports this clear thing

Is your own poo sweet smelling savour.


If what God requires was smoke, he wouldn't bother about what was burnt. so long as there's smoke he should be pleased. Shouldn't he?
Why would he insist on sweet smelling savour?

I don't do conspiracy theory and u know it.
Since we are going judaism tonight, then let me give u this...

SIRTee15:


Is your own poo sweet smelling savour.


If what God requires was smoke, he wouldn't bother about what was burnt. so long as there's smoke he should be pleased. Shouldn't he?
Why would he insist on sweet smelling savour?

I don't d-should-know-114790/conspiracy theory and u know it.
Since we are going judaism tonight, then let me give I this...

The verse talking about sweet smelling savor involved burning or do dead animals have sweet savor?

What goes up is smoke, smoke have smell.

SIRTee15:


Since we are going judaism tonight, then let me give u this...

This not judiasm but an article.

Olah in ALL CONTEXT always means Burnt sacrifice, one of the types of korban.

Maynman:

This not judiasm but an article

U gotta be kidding me.
Google prof rabbi Jonathan mangonet.

SIRTee15:

U gotta be kidding me.
Google prof rabbi Jonathan mangonet.

How is he "judaism"?

https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/8584-jephthah

Maynman:

How is he "judaism"?

https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/8584-jephthah

This is prof rabbi mangonet

SIRTee15:



This is prof rabbi mangonet

How is he judaism?
Is he talmud? Midrash? Tanakh?

Maynman:

The verse talking about sweet smelling savor involved burning or do dead animals have sweet savor?

What goes up is smoke, smoke have smell.

U not making sense anymore. I dont need to see smoke or smell smoke to perceive aroma of a food being cooked.
If I can smell smoke, then the food is burnt/overcooked.
Aroma is different from smoke. Learn this fact.

SIRTee15:


U not making sense anymore. I dont need to see smoke or smell smoke to perceive aroma of a food being cooked.
If I can smell smoke, then the food is burnt/overcooked

The sweet aroma in the verse is talking about BURNT offering, it's called offering made by fire.

Maynman:

The verse talking about sweet smelling savor involved burning or do dead animals have sweet savor?

What goes up is smoke, smoke have smell.

Since u not making sense anymore, I will end it here by proving numerous verses of aroma.

Genesis 8.20-21
Then Noah built an altar to the Lord and, taking some of all the clean animals and clean birds, he sacrificed burnt offerings on it. The Lord smelled the pleasing aroma and said in his heart: “Never again will I curse the ground because of humans,

Lev1.9
You are to wash the internal organs and the legs with water, and the priest is to burn all of it on the altar. It is a burnt offering, a food offering, an aroma pleasing to the Lord.

And burnt offering doesn't need to be animal. It could be plants.

Lev 2.2
[i]When anyone brings a grain offering to the Lord, their offering is to be of the finest flour. They are to pour olive oil on it, put incense on it 2 and take it to Aaron’s sons the priests. The priest shall take a handful of the flour and oil, together with all the incense, and burn this as a memorial[a] portion on the altar, a food offering, an aroma pleasing to the Lord.

Now show me anywhere in the bible God smelled the smoke from burnt offering and declared it pleasing. Just one.

Maynman:


How is he judaism?
Is he talmud? Midrash? Tanakh?

U asking a rabbi how he's Judaism?
The joke is on u.