Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,162,722 members, 7,851,466 topics. Date: Wednesday, 05 June 2024 at 08:02 PM

"Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" - Religion (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" (10322 Views)

Can God Forgive Satan Or Can Satan Ask For Forgiveness? / Will GOD Ever Forgive Satan? / Can God Ever Forgive Satan? (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 9:45pm On Dec 10, 2014
musKeeto:
Hhaahaaa. I thought sin was of the flesh. grin so spirits can sin too? cheesy

man is a spirit. he has a soul and lives in a body.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by chinnyonwu(m): 9:50pm On Dec 10, 2014
sonOfLucifer:

So why are you on this thread?
to see if there are any reasonable comments, unfortunately ur not helping
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by asala1: 9:55pm On Dec 10, 2014
Gombs:


You are so wrong.... blood was shed for forgiveness of sins... Goats, bulls etc

“The law requires that nearly everything be cleansed with blood, and without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness” (Heb. 9:22, NIV).

I said the OT bible. Even before Chirst died he instructed us to forgive unconditionally. He didn't say our enemies must seek forgiveness before we forgive them.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by chinnyonwu(m): 9:57pm On Dec 10, 2014
Gombs:


He did... it went so because He's given us all free will... even the devil. The devil deceived Eve, got the adamic authority, and ruled man in a terrible way, destroyed every beautiful thing God did... and God made a prophecy, that the seed of the woman would bruise the devil's head... Jesus was that seed.
he forsaw the deceit of eve by the devil even right from creation, and went ahead and created eve and gave her d "free will" knowin fully well that she would fall for the devils tricks and the world would eventually degrade to the level it is now wit billions of souls on the path of hell?
That God doesn't sound very reasonable to me.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 10:17pm On Dec 10, 2014
asala1:


I said the OT bible. Even before Chirst died he instructed us to forgive unconditionally. He didn't say our enemies must seek forgiveness before we forgive them.

See for yourself

Exo 30:10 Lev 16:2 Lev 16:34 Heb 9:7 [Lev 16:14]

There was not forgiveness of sins without shedding of blood
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 10:18pm On Dec 10, 2014
chinnyonwu:

he forsaw the deceit of eve by the devil even right from creation, and went ahead and created eve and gave her d "free will" knowin fully well that she would fall for the devils tricks and the world would eventually degrade to the level it is now wit billions of souls on the path of hell?
That God doesn't sound very reasonable to me.

You don't either
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Image123(m): 11:15pm On Dec 10, 2014
Forgiveness in this context is for the repentant. Also, Satan is already condemned and judged, unlike man.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by johnw74: 2:01am On Dec 11, 2014
One reason why satan may not be forgiven is because he inspired pharasees to say that Jesus performed miracles by the power of satan.
Saying that, is the unforgivable sin and satan is just as guilty as the pharasees for having inspired them to say it.

All the miracles Jesus performed were good, and good people would know that the Holy Spirit is the power behind them.
The pharasees calling Jesus's good miracles being from satan is blasphemy of the Holy Spirit, the sin never to be forgiven.

Mat 12:24 But when the Pharisees heard it, they said, This fellow doth not cast out devils, but by Beelzebub the prince of the devils.

Mat 12:32 And whosoever speaketh a word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him: but whosoever speaketh against the Holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this world, neither in the world to come.

satan can inspire us to sin:
Act 5:3 .....why hath Satan filled thine heart to lie to the Holy Ghost.....
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Nobody: 6:52am On Dec 11, 2014
My question is Esau as a man sought repentance with tears.why did God not forgive him?
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 7:40am On Dec 11, 2014
johnw74:
One reason why satan may not be forgiven is because he inspired pharasees to say that Jesus performed miracles by the power of satan.
Saying that, is the unforgivable sin and satan is just as guilty as the pharasees for having inspired them to say it.

All the miracles Jesus performed were good, and good people would know that the Holy Spirit is the power behind them.
The pharasees calling Jesus's good miracles being from satan is blasphemy of the Holy Spirit, the sin never to be forgiven.

Mat 12:24 But when the Pharisees heard it, they said, This fellow doth not cast out devils, but by Beelzebub the prince of the devils.

Mat 12:32 And whosoever speaketh a word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him: but whosoever speaketh against the Holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this world, neither in the world to come.

We mean, why wasn’t he forgiven when he rebelled and subsequently cast down?
satan can inspire us to sin:
Act 5:3 .....why hath Satan filled thine heart to lie to the Holy Ghost.....
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Image123(m): 7:41am On Dec 11, 2014
Bidam:
My question is Esau as a man sought repentance with tears.why did God not forgive him?

I think it was the birthright he sought. While God may forgive and save eternally, some things have consequences.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 7:42am On Dec 11, 2014
johnw74:
One reason why satan may not be forgiven is because he inspired pharasees to say that Jesus performed miracles by the power of satan.
Saying that, is the unforgivable sin and satan is just as guilty as the pharasees for having inspired them to say it.

All the miracles Jesus performed were good, and good people would know that the Holy Spirit is the power behind them.
The pharasees calling Jesus's good miracles being from satan is blasphemy of the Holy Spirit, the sin never to be forgiven.

Mat 12:24 But when the Pharisees heard it, they said, This fellow doth not cast out devils, but by Beelzebub the prince of the devils.

Mat 12:32 And whosoever speaketh a word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him: but whosoever speaketh against the Holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this world, neither in the world to come.


satan can inspire us to sin:
Act 5:3 .....why hath Satan filled thine heart to lie to the Holy Ghost.....

We mean, why wasn’t he forgiven when he rebelled and subsequently cast down?
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Nobody: 8:36am On Dec 11, 2014
Image123:


I think it was the birthright he sought. While God may forgive and save eternally, some things have consequences.
Yeah some things do have consequences and yet i kept wondering why God will disinherit esau's blessings which was his by birthright. Is it that esau made the mistake because he was hungry? Or God knew before they were born that esau will turn out the way he did.Even before they were born God already put the sentence on Esau( Romans 9:13) why is that so?
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 9:11am On Dec 11, 2014
Bidam:
Yeah some things do have consequences and yet i kept wondering why God will disinherit esau's blessings which was his by birthright. Is it that esau made the mistake because he was hungry? Or God knew before they were born that esau will turn out the way he did.Even before they were born God already put the sentence on Esau( Romans 9:13) why is that so?

My friend, God knows us before we were born, and I think innthe case of Esau, he was profane, and never regarded spiritual things, even though he was closest to Isaac (because of his meals though, nothing spiritual). Jacob on the other hand was mummy's boy, and his name was another wahala on its own.

God surely forgave Esau, and blessed him. But the consequence of his action cost him the line where the Messiah was to come. Was it God's will? No. God saw it, he told Rebecca, who may have told Isaac, what did Isaac do about it? Assuming she didn't tell Isaac, and she knew the importance of birthright, she must then have taught Jacob, who used that as a bait on Esau, Esau sold out...Isaac being controlled by his sense (he asked Esau to go prepare him a meal, so that his soul may bless him, he actually loved Esau more because of the meat Esau brought was delicious).

Rebecca heard, knowing Esau has sold his birthright, she connived with Jacob to deceive Isaac. I think, God saw this, Rebecca groomed Jacob for it.... Isaac on the other hand loved his son for the meal he brought, and probably didn't groom the young man in spiritual things.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Nobody: 10:08am On Dec 11, 2014
Gombs:


My friend, God knows us before we were born, and I think innthe case of Esau, he was profane, and never regarded spiritual things, even though he was closest to Isaac (because of his meals though, nothing spiritual). Jacob on the other hand was mummy's boy, and his name was another wahala on its own.

God surely forgave Esau, and blessed him. But the consequence of his action cost him the line where the Messiah was to come. Was it God's will? No. God saw it, he told Rebecca, who may have told Isaac, what did Isaac do about it? Assuming she didn't tell Isaac, and she knew the importance of birthright, she must then have taught Jacob, who used that as a bait on Esau, Esau sold out...Isaac being controlled by his sense (he asked Esau to go prepare him a meal, so that his soul may bless him, he actually loved Esau more because of the meat Esau brought was delicious).

Rebecca heard, knowing Esau has sold his birthright, she connived with Jacob to deceive Isaac. I think, God saw this, Rebecca groomed Jacob for it.... Isaac on the other hand loved his son for the meal he brought, and probably didn't groom the young man in spiritual things.
In other words it was the fault of isaac and rebecca that made esau turned out the way he did. I don't think i agree with your interpration here because jacob was also bad. It is not in terms of "works" but by election. God says he loved jacob and hated esau even before these guys were born and knew good from bad.It is always about God's choice not man.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by ayoku777(m): 10:33am On Dec 11, 2014
Bidam:
In other words it was the fault of isaac and rebecca that made esau turned out the way he did. I don't think i agree with your interpration here because jacob was also bad. It is not in terms of "works" but by election. God says he loved jacob and hated esau even before these guys were born and knew good from bad.It is always about God's choice not man.

Election is a very delicate matter honestly.

When and how God chooses to play or not to play his sovereignty card is as soveregn as the sovereignty itself.

There are some things in God's masterplan that we just have no power over.

While there are things He has given us the ability to determine the outcome.

Do you know I even discovered that our freewill is a gift of God's sovereignty. God in His sovereignty gave man a freewill. We didn't ask for it.

And there are things in His masterplan that our freewill has no control over.

We only need to realise that He is a good God and He loves us, and we can trust His plan on things we can't change or control.

And make the most positive use of the things He has given us the power to control.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Nobody: 10:36am On Dec 11, 2014
Gombs:


man is a spirit. he has a soul and lives in a body.
For once in your life be honest. Dont toe Joagbaje's path by answering questions no one asked.

Gal 5.17 For the flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit what is contrary to the flesh. They are in conflict with each other, so that you are not to do whatever you want.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by wordcat(m): 10:41am On Dec 11, 2014
9inches:
I never heard satan asked for forgiveness... He has pride

Did Satan write any book to say his own side of story?

Even in Yahweh's own book-the Bible, Yahweh killed more people than Satan, Yahweh made more mistakes than Satan, so how are u so sure that Yahweh is not the bad guy who chased Satan away from his kingdom?
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Nobody: 10:51am On Dec 11, 2014
ayoku777:


Election is a very delicate matter honestly.

When and how God chooses to play or not to play his sovereignty card is as soveregn as the sovereignty itself.

There are some things in God's masterplan that we just have no power over.

While there are things He has given us the ability to determine the outcome.

Do you know I even discovered that our freewill is a gift of God's sovereignty. God in His sovereignty gave man a freewill. We didn't ask for it.

And there are things in His masterplan that our freewill has no control over.

We only need to realise that He is a good God and He loves us, and we can trust His plan on things we can't change or control.

And make the most positive use of the things He has given us the power to control.
Yes i agree, very delicate i tell you. Paul made that analogy between the potter and the clay. We are just clay in the hands of the potter.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by chiedu7: 11:34am On Dec 11, 2014
sonOfLucifer:
Yahweh doesnt have the power to forgive Satan. HE has no jurisdiction over the affairs of Satan. Yahweh is like a spoilt kid that got too attached to his toys. He is a bully and a spoilt brat.
Humanity owes its salvation to Lucifer who shone light upon our darkened hearts. TODAY, OPEN YOUR HEART TO HIM. OPEN YOUR HEART TO KNOWLEDGE. KNOW THAT YOU ARE GOD. YOU CAN CREATE AND DESTROY. USE THE POWER WITHIN.

How can you say that Yahweh does not have power of your satan?

Was it not in the name of Yahweh that they kicked satan out of heaven?

If lucifer was strong, how come a fellow angel kicked him out.
Imagine if Yahweh Himself arose to deal with lucifer, dem for no see ein parts


Revelation 12 (KJV)

7 And there was war in heaven: Michael and his angels fought against the dragon; and the dragon fought and his angels,

8 And prevailed not; neither was their place found any more in heaven.

9 And the great dragon was cast out, that old serpent, called the Devil, and Satan, which deceiveth the whole world: he was cast out into the earth, and his angels were cast out with him.

10 And I heard a loud voice saying in heaven, Now is come salvation, and strength, and the kingdom of our God, and the power of his Christ: for the accuser of our brethren is cast down, which accused them before our God day and night.




sonOfLucifer BETTER GET RIGHT WITH JESUS NOW.

IF lUCIFER COULD NOT DEFEND HIMSELF, HOW CAN HE SAVE YOU FROM SINS
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by 9inches(m): 12:14pm On Dec 11, 2014
wordcat:


Did Satan write any book to say his own side of story?

Even in Yahweh's own book-the Bible, Yahweh killed more people than Satan, Yahweh made more mistakes than Satan, so how are u so sure that Yahweh is not the bad guy who chased Satan away from his kingdom?

Yahweh wrote the bible? Really?
Satan is still alive, so let him give his own account.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 12:34pm On Dec 11, 2014
Bidam:
In other words it was the fault of isaac and rebecca that made esau turned out the way he did. I don't think i agree with your interpration here because jacob was also bad. It is not in terms of "works" but by election. God says he loved jacob and hated esau even before these guys were born and knew good from bad.It is always about God's choice not man.

You have good points buddy! Romans 9:13-16 explains this better. wink
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 12:36pm On Dec 11, 2014
musKeeto:

For once in your life be honest. Dont toe Joagbaje's path by answering questions no one asked.

Gal 5.17 For the flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit what is contrary to the flesh. They are in conflict with each other, so that you are not to do whatever you want.

You made no point buddy! Or at least, I did not see any. Could you be any plainer?
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Gombs(m): 12:38pm On Dec 11, 2014
9inches:


Yahweh wrote the bible? Really?
Satan is still alive, so let him give his own account.

Gbam

1 Like

Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by dorox(m): 1:18pm On Dec 11, 2014
@ Gombs. Was Adam forgiven?
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by wordcat(m): 2:51pm On Dec 11, 2014
9inches:


Yahweh wrote the bible? Really?
Satan is still alive, so let him give his own account.

Yahweh inspired those that wrote the bible, in other words, he's the Author of the bible.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by vooks: 3:17pm On Dec 11, 2014
Loser,
Do you love hearing your own confusion or what?
Let me share with you the end game

Revelation 20:10 (KJV)
And the devil that deceived them was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are, and shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever.


The only thing your father wins is eternal damnation
sonOfLucifer:

Eve was not deceived. The light of knowledge attracted her. Light naturally draws us. Humans will always continue to seek light. We will prevail and there is nothing your God can do to stop us. A large portion of humanity will be in hell. YOUR GOD LOSES AT THE END. AS ALWAYS.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Nobody: 3:23pm On Dec 11, 2014
vooks:
Loser,
Do you love hearing your own confusion or what?
Let me share with you the end game

Revelation 20:10 (KJV)
And the devil that deceived them was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are, and shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever.


The only thing your father wins is eternal damnation
You will be with me in hell. That I can assure you.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Image123(m): 4:57pm On Dec 11, 2014
Bidam:
Yeah some things do have consequences and yet i kept wondering why God will disinherit esau's blessings which was his by birthright. Is it that esau made the mistake because he was hungry? Or God knew before they were born that esau will turn out the way he did.Even before they were born God already put the sentence on Esau( Romans 9:13) why is that so?

That's one of the not so easy questions, i would only share my thoughts/opinions . There are differences in its understanding and that is permitted. It's teaching is not saving faith or something required for us to be saved or whatever. i was trying to explain something similar to italo about holding differing positions/understandings. Again, my THOUGHTS are that Esau made a mistake AND God knew before they were born. i think it is so because God is omniscient. Being omniscient doesn't exactly mean that He did it, but that He knew it. i think its like a pregnant woman going to the doctor and the doctor knows the gender of the baby, time of delivery, health of the baby etc. It's a projection of knowledge that was not feasible about two centuries ago. The doctor knows but is not necessarily the cause. Also, things can change in between, like there may be premature delivery or death or some other thing caused by other factors. i think that is the way God sees us, though in a more advanced way. He can project as it were, but of course there needs to be a conception before a projection as it were. He probably has various simulations from the sperm cells and eggs, the millions of scenarios into the future, and then zoomed in into the lucky sperm. i'll call it an omniscient permission, not a sentence.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by davien(m): 5:01pm On Dec 11, 2014
Image123:


That's one of the not so easy questions, i would only share my thoughts/opinions . There are differences in its understanding and that is permitted. It's teaching is not saving faith or something required for us to be saved or whatever. i was trying to explain something similar to italo about holding differing positions/understandings. Again, my THOUGHTS are that Esau made a mistake AND God knew before they were born. i think it is so because God is omniscient. Being omniscient doesn't exactly mean that He did it, but that He knew it. i think its like a pregnant woman going to the doctor and the doctor knows the gender of the baby, time of delivery, health of the baby etc. It's a projection of knowledge that was not feasible about two centuries ago. The doctor knows but is not necessarily the cause. Also, things can change in between, like there may be premature delivery or death or some other thing caused by other factors. i think that is the way God sees us, though in a more advanced way. He can project as it were, but of course there needs to be a conception before a projection as it were. He probably has various simulations from the sperm cells and eggs, the millions of scenarios into the future, and then zoomed in into the lucky sperm. i'll call it an omniscient permission, not a sentence.
Omniprescence and omnipotence reduces your excuse to shambles....
Unless you believe your "god" is the same as a pregnant woman...hence incapable of changing any situation... undecided

1 Like

Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by vooks: 5:08pm On Dec 11, 2014
He won't be alone, you are joining him except you turn to the Creator, Jesus the King of Kings

Rev 20:15 (KJV)
15 And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire.


sonOfLucifer:

You will be with me in hell. That I can assure you.
Re: "Why Couldn't God Forgive Satan?" by Nobody: 5:29pm On Dec 11, 2014
Forgive my bombom

(1) (2) (3) (Reply)

11111 / If you love GOD, keep HIS Commandments (john 14:15) / Bishop Ugokwe Leads Other Clerics To Offer Prayers For Tinubu, Shettima, Others

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 83
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.