Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,156,059 members, 7,828,735 topics. Date: Wednesday, 15 May 2024 at 01:27 PM

He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. - Islam for Muslims - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. (19579 Views)

Can We Attribute An Ear To Allah? / She Called Her; "Selfish First Wife!!!" / Polygamy (Polygyny): "Should I live with his second wife" and lots more (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (Reply) (Go Down)

He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by smallrincowis16(m): 9:23pm On Aug 20, 2020
Question

I am married and my wife no longer gets her menses. Is it permissible, according to Islam, to marry another wife with the aim of taking an egg from her and implanting it in the uterus of my current wife, and producing a child who will be kept by my current wife, and we will attribute him to us? If that is not permissible, is it permissible for me to marry a woman so that she will bear me a child in the natural way, and I will attribute him to myself and my current wife, after his birth mother agrees to that?

Answer

Praise be to Allah.


Firstly: 

The first idea, of implanting an egg from one woman into the uterus of another woman, is not permissible. A statement was issued by the Islamic Fiqh Council concerning the issue of implanting a fertilised egg from a couple into the uterus of another woman, stating that this is not permissible, even if the woman in whom the egg is implanted is the second wife of the husband himself.

Secondly: 

The child can only be attributed to his real parents. Allah, may He be exalted, says (interpretation of the meaning):

“nor has He made your adopted sons your real sons. That is but your saying with your mouths. But Allah says the truth, and He guides to the (Right) Way.

Call them (adopted sons) by (the names of) their fathers, that is more just with Allah”

[al-Ahzab 33:4, 5]. 

Based on that, it is not permissible to attribute the child to anyone but his real mother who gave birth to him. This is the kind of adoption that is prohibited. That is because attributing him to someone other than his real mother may result in negative consequences, one of which is that he would inherit from that woman on the basis that she is his mother, when in fact she is not, and this would be a transgression of people’s rights. Moreover, people may regard that child as a mahram of someone for whom he is not a mahram, such as a maternal uncle or aunt, or vice versa. 

Conclusion: 

It is not permissible for you to seek to have a child in the manner mentioned. It is also not permissible for you to marry another woman so that you can attribute her child to your first wife. 

You have other, permissible means of having a child, such as marrying a second wife. In that case, if Allah blesses you with children from her, there is no reason why the first wife cannot take care of the upbringing of some of the children of the second wife, as a way of bringing her comfort and consolation by having children around her. If it is not possible to marry a second wife, but you can take care of an orphan, then we advise you to try to do that, but without attributing the child to yourself or to your wife, unless she actually gave birth to him. 


We ask Allah to bestow upon you righteous offspring, for He is able to do that. 

And Allah knows best.


https://islamqa.info/en/answers/186347/he-wants-to-attribute-his-child-from-his-second-wife-to-his-first-wife-because-she-cannot-have-children-what-is-the-ruling

15 Likes 6 Shares

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by XXXXTENTACION: 9:35pm On Aug 20, 2020
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death

27 Likes 1 Share

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Arry110(m): 9:45am On Aug 21, 2020
.
Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by NeoWanZaeed(m): 9:45am On Aug 21, 2020
perfect

2 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by BoboNogoDie: 9:47am On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death

HYPOCRISY is when you tried to criticise others when you're even worse....


Jehovah witness that are Christians, is it permissible?

Do they even approve of ordinary blood transfusion?

So many fools just like commenting on what doesn't concern them...

26 Likes 5 Shares

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Jahzrockballer(m): 9:51am On Aug 21, 2020
Ok

2 Likes 2 Shares

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Diamondniyi(m): 9:51am On Aug 21, 2020
wink
Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by BHUHARiE: 9:52am On Aug 21, 2020
May Allah Reward you



Non Muslim be careful with your Comment May Allah Reward you



Non Muslim be careful with your Comment
May Allah Reward you



Non Muslim be careful with your Comment

5 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Protein0: 9:52am On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy(sic) and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death
The summary is that, no matter your way of trying to get children, children should not be denied their biological roots.

Assisted Reproductive Technology is an area of science with many ethical cautions. The bottomline is, you're either the biological parent or not. There are no two ways to it, except you want to deceive yourself.
You can see from the Quranic verse quoted, you can adopt but don't deny the adopted child his biological root. That's fairness.

26 Likes 1 Share

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by ThatFairGuy: 9:52am On Aug 21, 2020
Jazzakumullahu khayran OP. Islam is based on principles, not ordinary views. Who doesn't know should take note

4 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Mtm5313: 9:52am On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death
[quote author=XXXXTENTACION post=93043194]Too bad embarassed



it is allowed it they are legally married

1 Like

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Techreliance(m): 9:53am On Aug 21, 2020
smallrincowis16:
Question

I am married and my wife no longer gets her menses. Is it permissible, according to Islam, to marry another wife with the aim of taking an egg from her and implanting it in the uterus of my current wife, and producing a child who will be kept by my current wife, and we will attribute him to us? If that is not permissible, is it permissible for me to marry a woman so that she will bear me a child in the natural way, and I will attribute him to myself and my current wife, after his birth mother agrees to that?

Answer

Praise be to Allah.


Firstly: 

The first idea, of implanting an egg from one woman into the uterus of another woman, is not permissible. A statement was issued by the Islamic Fiqh Council concerning the issue of implanting a fertilised egg from a couple into the uterus of another woman, stating that this is not permissible, even if the woman in whom the egg is implanted is the second wife of the husband himself.

Secondly: 

The child can only be attributed to his real parents. Allah, may He be exalted, says (interpretation of the meaning):

“nor has He made your adopted sons your real sons. That is but your saying with your mouths. But Allah says the truth, and He guides to the (Right) Way.

Call them (adopted sons) by (the names of) their fathers, that is more just with Allah”

[al-Ahzab 33:4, 5]. 

Based on that, it is not permissible to attribute the child to anyone but his real mother who gave birth to him. This is the kind of adoption that is prohibited. That is because attributing him to someone other than his real mother may result in negative consequences, one of which is that he would inherit from that woman on the basis that she is his mother, when in fact she is not, and this would be a transgression of people’s rights. Moreover, people may regard that child as a mahram of someone for whom he is not a mahram, such as a maternal uncle or aunt, or vice versa. 

Conclusion: 

It is not permissible for you to seek to have a child in the manner mentioned. It is also not permissible for you to marry another woman so that you can attribute her child to your first wife. 

You have other, permissible means of having a child, such as marrying a second wife. In that case, if Allah blesses you with children from her, there is no reason why the first wife cannot take care of the upbringing of some of the children of the second wife, as a way of bringing her comfort and consolation by having children around her. If it is not possible to marry a second wife, but you can take care of an orphan, then we advise you to try to do that, but without attributing the child to yourself or to your wife, unless she actually gave birth to him. 


We ask Allah to bestow upon you righteous offspring, for He is able to do that. 

And Allah knows best.


https://islamqa.info/en/answers/186347/he-wants-to-attribute-his-child-from-his-second-wife-to-his-first-wife-because-she-cannot-have-children-what-is-the-ruling


Alhamdulillah Allah nimoti'l Islam wa sunnah.

11 Likes 1 Share

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Patrioticman007(m): 9:54am On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death

You can deceive your relatives not yourself & God.

5 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Youright: 9:55am On Aug 21, 2020
God bless the living and rest the dead

Isha Allah

There is no religion in heaven

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by swtdrms(m): 9:55am On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death

You better live forever with your confusion. This is islam, it doesn't need to make sense to you, go and deal with the confusions in your religion and leave others to theirs.

5 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Vengazi: 10:01am On Aug 21, 2020
Please i need assistance in translating these names to arabic

1. Rafiu (male)
2. Latifat (Female)
3. Nafisat (Female

Would really appreciate
Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by BoboNogoDie: 10:03am On Aug 21, 2020
swtdrms:


You better live forever with your confusion. This is islam, it doesn't need to make sense to you, go and deal with the confusions in your religion and leave others to theirs.

Don't mind them

RUBBISH!

There are over 2000 gods in this world...
There are over 200 known religious books...

Why should I believe in their Jesus?

Why should I believe in their story book - Bible?

What makes their Jesus special?

How sure are they that their Jesus is the true god? A mere human like you and I...

Oh! I see, they have a story book (Bible) that says so.  As if other religions don't have their story books too 
Let's assume the pale skinned slave masters from Europe didn't invade their land hundreds of years ago to STEAL, RAPE, KILL, DESTROY AND TO PREACH ABOUT JESUS, will they be here defending this RUBBISH?

3 Likes 1 Share

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by disco82: 10:04am On Aug 21, 2020
perfect answer. May Almighty Allah bless every marriage looking for child with fruit of womb.

4 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Nobody: 10:05am On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death
Must one bear children?

2 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by fraymite: 10:08am On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death
Artifical insemination is allowed if only the husband sperm is transferred to his wife's egg and the wife carried the pregnancy herself (please note all the conditions attached)
Surrogacy is totally haram in Islam.
Adoption is allowed but you must never claim to be the biological parent of that child. You can only be guardian and also let the child knows the root of her real parent when grown up.

7 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Amspecial: 10:13am On Aug 21, 2020
grin
Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by Princeofasia: 10:13am On Aug 21, 2020
rubbish, all in the name of allah.
Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by flimzy24: 10:36am On Aug 21, 2020
.
Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by marod(m): 11:41am On Aug 21, 2020
BoboNogoDie:


Don't mind them

RUBBISH!

There are over 2000 gods in this world...
There are over 200 known religious books...

Why should I believe in their Jesus?

Why should I believe in their story book - Bible?

What makes their Jesus special?

How sure are they that their Jesus is the true god? A mere human like you and I...

Oh! I see, they have a story book (Bible) that says so.  As if other religions don't have their story books too 
Let's assume the pale skinned slave masters from Europe didn't invade their land hundreds of years ago to STEAL, RAPE, KILL, DESTROY AND TO PREACH ABOUT JESUS, will they be here defending this RUBBISH?

I am guessing you are part of 'them' that you are referring to. This is not of Muslims. We don't troll other religions.

5 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by jagunpapa(m): 11:46am On Aug 21, 2020
Jazakumullahu khaeeran

2 Likes

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by AbuAeesha: 12:10pm On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death
also in some Christianity too, even wen one of the couple is impotent they have to Live together like that,till DEATH DO US APART.
some xtians don't even allow blood transfusion for the purpose of saving a life
Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by bamevoj: 12:47pm On Aug 21, 2020
Have you register for September Class?
This is the perfect course for those who want to start a career as an Event planner/ Manager. It's a fast paced course that can be completed in as little as 4 weeks and covers all elements of Event Planning and Management. 3 month of mentoring and internship and One year business support.
During the course, you will complete a series of projects allowing you to grow by putting your skills to the test. You will work with a professional wedding planner, your teacher and mentor who is there to review your work and help you improve. You will earn a wedding planning certificate that you can use to obtain a job in this exciting field.

WHAT YOU WILL LEARN
After completing the course, students will be able to: *Turn his or her love for weddings and events into a career as a professional. *Demonstrate skills on how to work with different kinds of clients, meet their needs and answer their questions.
Discuss how to work with vendors, photographers and caterers etc . *Succeed at planning a perfect day for clients.
Discuss wedding attire, floral, decor, photography, and transportation recommendations. *Indicate business skills needed to find and sign clients, price his or her work, and help him or her improve. *Demonstrate skills in how to manage client expectations and emotions that come with the wedding planning.
Show how rituals, traditions and customs can be combined to create a special ceremony. *Understand the use of theme and how to create one.

WHAT YOU GET
*You will get access to expertly prepared Event planning course materials .
*Event business Documents and Templates. *Free event business Resource, One-to-one feedback from a professional event planner as your mentor there to help you improve. *Access to a team of advisors available by phone, whatsApp and email to answer all your questions. *Access to our student forum an online community to discuss courses, get answers to your questions, and share your work. *Your Professional Certificate will be delivered upon graduation.
————————————————————
TO REGISTER TRAINING .
Register with link in bio
CONTACT:
Temi 07060590242

Re: He Wants To Attribute His Child From His Second Wife To His First Wife. by abdullahi45: 1:04pm On Aug 21, 2020
XXXXTENTACION:
Too bad embarassed



so you mean artificial insemination, sorrugacy and adoption is not allowed in islam am confused .


what if in the case a woman or man has an accident or contacts a disease and he or she's not able to produce children does that mean such a person will remain childless till death

Hi. Read the write-up again, I think you must have missed some critical points. Your response says it all.

(1) (2) (Reply)

A Thread on Correcting Errors Made in Salat / Unidentified Woman Dies During Hajj Pilgrimage In Saudi Arabia. Photo / Islamically, Is It Permissible To Divorce My Husband Based On Polygamy?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 58
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.