Maynman:

You can force your brain to visualise whatever that’s why some people think they have seen jesus or their mystical leaders, but at the end of the day it’s all still imagination.

Where do people get ideas from ?

triplechoice:

Where do people get ideas from ?

From their mind.

Maynman:

From their mind.

How do you get it from the mind ?

triplechoice:


How do you get it from the mind ?

Where is the mind in the body?

Maynman:

Where is the mind in the body?

Is this an answer to "how do you get it from the mind ?

triplechoice:


Is this an answer to "how do you get it from the mind ?

Who are you to be demanding answers from me?
I already answered your question, answer mine too.

Let’s learn together.

Where is the mind located in the body?

triplechoice:


Is this an answer to "how do you get it from the mind ?

You have said 2 things here already.
Who is the “you” that is getting it from the “mind”?

How do “you” get your sight from the eye?
How do “you” get your ideas from the mind?

Who is the you?

Maynman:

You have said 2 things here already.
Who is the “person” that is getting it from the “mind”?

How do “you” get your sight from the eye?
How do “you” get your ideas from the mind?

Who is the you?

This is not relevant now.
I ask you where do people get ideas from?

You replied, from the mind
To get something from somewhere, one needs to do something.

So what can one do ?
Or how do we go about getting ideas 'from the mind?

triplechoice:


This is not relevant now.
I ask you where do people get ideas from?

You replied, from the mind
To get something from somewhere, one needs to do something.

So what can one do ?
Or how do we go about getting ideas 'from the mind?

The question you are asking is absurd.

You asked me where do people get ideas from, and i told you the “mind”, then you coined another irrelevant question about how to get it from the mind, like the mind is a physical object.
So i want you to define what “mind” means, you have one right? and show where it is located, then i will tell you how you can get it from the mind.

Is like asking me how do you get your sight from the eye?

triplechoice:



To get something from somewhere, one needs to do something.

To get your sight from the eye, what do you need to do?

triplechoice:

Where do people get ideas from ?

This question is even wrong phrasing.
People don’t “get” ideas from anywhere, they don’t go collecting it.

It arises from the mind.

Maynman:

This question is even wrong phrasing.
People don’t get ideas from anywhere, they don’t collect it.

It arises from the mind.

So without thinking, ideas just arises from the mind?

triplechoice:


So without thinking, ideas just arises from the mind?

Yes.

You have never had evil thoughts before that was never your thinking?
You get millions of ideas everyday, you get flashes of your childhood memories without you thinking, you suddenly remember some people without you thinking about them.
Come on, ideas arises without you trying.

triplechoice:


So without thinking, ideas just arises from the mind?

And if you notice, anytime you think you are only talking to yourself.
And when you are talking, you stop thinking.
You can’t talk and think at the same time.

Maynman:

And if you notice, anytime you think you are only talking to yourself.
And when you are talking, you stop thinking.
You can’t talk and think at the same time.

Talking to yourself is not the same as thinking; rehashing existiing thoughts in your head or generating new ones

Thoughts goes first before talking, either aloud or silently to oneself

triplechoice:


Talking to yourself is not the same as thinking; rehashing existiing thoughts in your head or generating new ones

Thoughts goes first before talking, either aloud or silently to oneself

I said anytime you are thinking you are only talking to yourself.

You don’t need mouth to talk to yourself, and you don’t near ears to hear yourself.

You can’t talk aloud and think at the same time.

triplechoice:


rehashing existiing thoughts in your head or generating new ones

You are not a body, you have a body, exactly, “your head”, “your leg”, “your car”, “your house” “ your mind” “your eye”.
Who owns them?

Maynman:

You are not a body, you have a body, exactly, “your head”, “your leg”, “your car”, “your house” “ your mind” “your eye”.
Who owns them?

We are talking about where ideas come from. Let's stick to that first

triplechoice:

We are talking about where ideas come from. Let's stick to that first

It’s wrong phrasing.

Ideas don’t come from anywhere, they arises from the mind.

triplechoice:

We are talking about where ideas come from. Let's stick to that first

Are you talking about thought out ideas that you have planned in your “mind”?

Maynman:

It’s wrong phrasing.

Ideas don’t come from anywhere, they arises from the mind.

So what is mind to you?

Your answer will clear something for me

triplechoice:


So what is mind to you?

Your answer will clear something for me

First define what you mean by “ideas”.

Then i will better understand what you mean by “getting” it.

Maynman:

Are you talking about thought out ideas that you have planned in your “mind”?

A thought, conception or notion that has occur to you or the ones you deliberately create.
You don't seem to agree that people can consciously visualize or conceptualize something within themselves and then go on to do things to bring it to fruition.

You said they only "arises from the mind", meaning people have no control over anything

triplechoice:


A thought, conception or notion that has occur to you

What do you mean by this?

triplechoice:


You don't seem to agree that peoples can consciously visualize or conceptualize something within themselves and then go on to do things to bring it to fruition.

If people can consciously think about something, where then is the “ideas” from? Is it not from their thinking? You answered yourself.
😂😂

Maynman:


What do you mean by this?

That is very clear.
You don't know what a thought is?

triplechoice:


That is very clear.
You don't know what a thought is?

What is the shape of a thought and where is it located?

You said a thought that has occur to you. That means the thoughts is not from your own thinking lol
It’s after it occurred to you, you started thinking about it, yet you said one can’t get ideas without thinking.

“without thinking, ideas just arises from the mind?”

Maynman:

If people can consciously think about something, where then is the “ideas” from? Is it not from their thinking? You answered yourself.
😂😂

So you agree all along that people do something ,thinking, to get ideas and not that they just "arises from the mind"

Or what do you mean by "arises from the mind"?
The same?

triplechoice:

So you agree all along that people do something ,thinking, to get ideas and not that they just "arises from the mind"

Or what do you mean by "arises from the mind"?
The same?

😂😂
You said Where do ideas come from, same you still said people consciously think about something.

You should have framed your question, “where do plans come from”. 😂

Maynman:

What is the shape of a thought and where is it located?

You said a thought that has occur to you. That means the thoughts is not from your own thinking lol
It’s after it occurred to you, you started thinking about it, yet you said one can’t get ideas without thinking.

“without thinking, ideas just arises from the mind?”

Where did I say one can't get ideas without thinking?
You are the one who suggested that with your "arises from the mind

triplechoice:


Where did I say one can't get ideas without thinking?
You are the one who suggested that with your "arises from the mind

What does this mean?

triplechoice:


Where did I say one can't get ideas without thinking?
You are the one who suggested that with your "arises from the mind

Can you think without your mind?

When people say “you are out of your mind” what do they mean?