Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,156,100 members, 7,828,845 topics. Date: Wednesday, 15 May 2024 at 03:00 PM

Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos - Culture (10) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Culture / Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos (19541 Views)

Why Is The Yoruba Not United In Business & Politics / The main reasons Yoruba not enlisted as a tribe in Edo state / They" Say YORUBA Are Cowards Really? (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) ... (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Thebadpolitican(m): 10:01am On Dec 07, 2023
Beuberry:

So common sense didn't tell you it was Yoruba influence in Edo that made them not only influence the palace but have people so close to them. Since you v agreed Ogun, Ayelala, Olokun etc are Yoruba boys, no qualms.
Mind you, Benin people dey worship Ogun so don't say you guys are animists. Ogun was one of the oga welders for ancient Yoruba times. He's very talented & was given war Chief title. Anyways am not her to teach you history as a priestess.
My msg to you is clear now. You n gregboy v the right to protect ya heritage but don't do so with lies on another people's own. Me personally wished Yorubas cut ties with Benin cos it's indeed Ile-Ibinu, land of vexation. Naso una take annoy Oranyan that time & that man na hot tempered person.
Peace!

I never said ogun, ayelala and olokun are yoruba idols I said they are Benin owned idol

You seem not to even read my writeups you just glance through and reply me, if you keep doing that I will be forced to stop engaging you it shows your outmost unseriousness on your part
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Procashtips(m): 10:07am On Dec 07, 2023
Raf4:


Do I need to school you about Bini expedition? How Oba of Bini sent his warriors to Lagos because of constant disputes between the Aworis and Bini traders? Go and read many history books on how Bini invaded and established Obaship in Lagos. Just because Aworis were blocking his access and control of trading activities in Lagos.

Again, tales by moonlight.

Post the evidence stating that Benin Kingdom conquered the Aworis which led to them pay tax to the former.

Is this too hard to do?

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Thebadpolitican(m): 10:14am On Dec 07, 2023
Beuberry:

You, gregboy and other Benin scavengers has been roaming this site spewing tràsh. Your statements are incoherent cos of lies you spill. You ll carry screenshots that even pointed more fact that Yorubas had more influence on Benins. While I reply all ya lies with truth, I ll rough handle you with more facts, logic & common sense posts to show that you are just a strong head boy like Ologbosere, the fetish chief that ill-advised Oba Ovonramwen.
Na that string head dey make you disregard Yoruba history from Benin.
Before you cough, what's the meaning of the word Benin?


Have you read my writeups I told you to read

No you didn't you're making my work difficult

I will help you out

The name Benin was giving by the itsekiri unknowingly, they were the first who encounterd the Europeans in the benin river and they inquired about a big town nearby they could visit and the itsekiris replied there is a big town, but warned not to go there and that It's the land of anger, Ile binu!
which the Portuguese picked up and simply corrupted as Benin in their documentation

Can we move on now,

Have you wonder why our neighbours called the Benins the variant name of edo, some Idu, ado, idun but never a variant of the word Benin because the Portuguese were the only ones who called us that, the Benins till date call themselves edo, Benin is more of an English name or political identity

You're a lady, leave this argument for men and accept the fact that all you think you knew was
A lie from the beginning
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Boyooosa(m): 10:16am On Dec 07, 2023
Thebadpolitican:



Do you mean the aworis occupied every space in lagos, haha before Benin moved the capital of lagos from Badagry to lagos island, Lagos island was completely virginated, Benin were the first to settle in that area and soon trading began that brought in even the aworis benin controlled every part of lagos including ikeja

So aworis alone do not own lagos, they own a large portion does not mean it's for them only

May be the ancestral Binis settled in a part of Lagos island as reflected by all the reports we have here, even your own account affirms that.

My major concern and how I think we can fix this is, when the ancestral Binis migrated to Lagos Island and settled there, did they meet anyone or clan in the land?
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by SayNo2SmallPrik: 10:18am On Dec 07, 2023
Thebadpolitican:

I blame my useless father who can't control his urge and sired me
Yes ooo. Blame him very well.
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by shonepa(m): 10:49am On Dec 07, 2023
Thats why it called History.....lol

ShangTsung000:
Abeg this story is stale nau. Who discover Lagos? And then. Abegi.
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Thebadpolitican(m): 10:51am On Dec 07, 2023
SayNo2SmallPrik:

Yes ooo. Blame my dad very well. Yoruba dad's are something else

I see why you insult your parents openly, don't
Let your parents action determine who you become better still see a therapist
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Beuberry(f): 10:52am On Dec 07, 2023
Thebadpolitican:



I don't see any similarities between Benin and Ife artwork, apart from the fact that both artworks you posted are both bust fiqures, that's is due to the fact that you only selected a Benin artwork you think look similar with Ife artwork but then again you failed...

The Benin artwork you posted does not have an open head space in the back, but all Ife artworks does including the one you posted

The eye designs in the Benin artwork you posted is different from that of Ife, the Benin artwork is less realistic

So I am asking where is the similarities in their tongue?

I am not stressing myself to educate you but to humiliate you and appeal to your inner mind to sink in the truth and also to the people that will come across this thread in the future...

My Screenshot shows both side views of Benin and Ife artworks

Lastly Did ife own their artworks?

The answer is no, the facial scarification in the Ife artworks was never in practice by the Ife people, the crown on the Ife artwork was recently copied by the current ooni, it was never in use before now... The assumed Oba olufun artwork attire was recently copied
Unlike the Benin artworks that represent their cultural attire even till date....

Our educational system is dead so stop using that as refrence, our educational sys is there to promote false unity between tribes, so if they can draw similarities between Benin and Ife art then it their usual madness

Lastly you said we should thank Egharevba lol, do you know he later corrected most of his baseless earliest works, I guess you're unaware that's why you're praising is old works....


Benin helped the yoruba into Organization my point is Ife and Benin never had any connection, Benin ruled over lagos, ogun, ekiti, ondo and defeated oyo, Benin presence in the yoruba culture is everywhere we built what is yoruba culture today...
How you wan take humiliate the truth? You just disgraced yaself. In your bid to discredit Yorubas you opened up more truth that depicts Benin Yorubas relationship which started when Odede was ya first king.
You said Nigeria education system is dead but others were able to carbe out their history except Benins. If ya educational systems them, wetin come concern Yorubas.
It's obvious the 1897 nuking of Benin by the British has entered ya brain. Possibly you be Ologbosere's descendant cos the string head of suffer for nothing showed clearly on ya head.
Looking at ya name Thebadpolitician, one would see that you are indeed cantankerous in mind.
All you wrote were just secondary school tales.


Now let's examine ya lies.
1. When did Benin & Oyo fight battle sotey Benin defeated Oyo forces? Shey na Dahomey you dey claim? Dahomey wey be half Yoruba & half Ewe? Those ones sef get better brain?

2. If you said Ife no get artworks, who come get am?
The artworks had names. You said the king of Ife just dey dress like the Ife bronze. Do you v any pic of any early Ife kings to determine their look? Why are you so pained about progress of Yorubas? I thought ya concern should be the north? Who do you juju sotey ya brain come mad?

3. Egharevba made adjustments to his analysis cos Ologboseres like you threatened him.

4. Benin & Ife art are so similar. Na jealousy of Ife naturalism that's worrying you.

5. You said I selected just one similar Benin art to that of Ife when there are numerous online. The jealousy of Yorubas from you has eaten ya sense! You said the artworks has open head & Benin no get. Can't their be change in styles? Must Benins do copy & pastor A-Zee? Ancient Benins wise pass you cos if ma you na copy n paste as you did in school you go do.


* Ife & Benin artworks has beaded necks
* Both made busts to depict head as source of life
* Both are made in bronze casting
* Both showed artworks controlled by influence of the palace
* Both are memorial artworks.
* Both has intricate decorations & more.
Below is pic of Oba Oguola and another image of an Ige king and queen. Dressing in similar style to depict there was similarities from ancient times.
Pic 1 Benin
Pic 2 Ife
Pic 3 Benin queen mother
Pic 4 Ife ancient queen image.
Look at the eyes o, the stylized eyes, beads, head etc.
Are you still blind to see the similarities, dear Uncle modern day Ologbosere?

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by gbengene1234(m): 10:54am On Dec 07, 2023
Killermamba:
confuse mumu like seun, you have all the histories yet the origin and birth of tinubu is unknown.

Good point so far 👌
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by SayNo2SmallPrik: 11:05am On Dec 07, 2023
Thebadpolitican:


I won’t stop insulting my parents openly cuz they didn’t teach me well
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Omobude244: 11:06am On Dec 07, 2023
Raf4:


He came from Obadio family in Ile-Ife or do you know the name of his parents in igodomigodo?
nor be only Obadio
na ObaFM grin

How did Obadio come about?
who are they in Ife?
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Thebadpolitican(m): 11:10am On Dec 07, 2023
Boyooosa:


May be the ancestral Binis settled in a part of Lagos island as reflected by all the reports we have here, even your own account affirms that.

My major concern and how I think we can fix this is, when the ancestral Binis migrated to Lagos Island and settled there, did they meet anyone or clan in the land?


They didn't meet anyone there Benin were the first to occupy the area and open it for trade inshort the Europeans and the Benins where the first to set their eyes on the inhabited lagos island both Benins and the Europeans agreed to setup a trade centre at lagos island which soon took place, the then Benin capital in lagos was still in Badagry before it was later moved the island

. You should know that population wasn't much in the past so people tend to conglomerate in one place under a larger population for both protection and everything

The Benins only had 3 people occupying lagos
As noted by a Dutch ethnographer who took account but that of Badagry was occupied by people Before the arrival of Benin it was there the Benin and aworis war took place
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Beuberry(f): 11:20am On Dec 07, 2023
Thebadpolitican:



Read the works of babatunde lawal on Benin and Ife artwork
https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.jstor.org/stable/180516&sa=U&ved=2ahUKEwjvtbjk6PyCAxWJUkEAHYO0B9wQFnoECAkQAg&usg=AOvVaw1f20jqc1Jx-3X7iGPGK0zJ

There is the link or you can help yourself with the screenshot
You ended up shooting yaself in the foot. You eben helped ya sister with more evidence to my studies. Thank you o, Ologbosere descendant. I just researched Tunde Lawal's works and ge made lots of common sense. It helps confirm the following:
* It was Leo Frobenius that was so astonished and linked Ife art to classical Greek art. Cos it shocked him.

* Same Leo Frobenius discovered Benin hot casters from Ife during reign of Oguola. If someone said Oguola reigned in 12th century and another saying it's 13th or 14th century, all join. It's cos radiocarbon dating gives estimates which may not be 100% exact date but at least gives expected estimates. Wikipedia sef said Oguola lived around 12th century. Now listen mu brother, if you can't believe African oral tradition that was backed up with discoveries, artworks & scientific dating then how come you believed ya own Benin oral tradition?
Don't be biased. Benin-Ife had relations. Oranyan is ya first king. Swallow ya pride. Yorubas are t hurting Benin by helping them with more facts to their history.
Lastly, I m a daughter of history so I v reason to state facts. Ya screenshot was helpful.

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Pauladex(m): 11:21am On Dec 07, 2023
slivertongue:
Well Yorubas own Lagos today but the binis & ijaws were there before them. Even archeological artifacts found in places in Lagos gives evidence to that effect.
Clap for yourself
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Raf4: 11:25am On Dec 07, 2023
Omobude244:

nor be only Obadio
na ObaFM grin

How did Obadio come about?
who are they in Ife?

Tell us the names of Obagodo's parents in igodomigodo or Bini land. Does the name Obagodo sound edoid to you?
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Boyooosa(m): 11:28am On Dec 07, 2023
Thebadpolitican:



They didn't meet anyone there Benin were the first to occupy the area and open it for trade inshort the Europeans and the Benins where the first to set their eyes on the inhabited lagos island both Benins and the Europeans agreed to setup a trade centre at lagos island which soon took place, the then Benin capital in lagos was still in Badagry before it was later moved the island

. You should know that population wasn't much in the past so people tend to conglomerate in one place under a larger population for both protection and everything

The Benins only had 3 people occupying lagos
As noted by a Dutch ethnographer who took account but that of Badagry was occupied by people Before the arrival of Benin it was there the Benin and aworis war took place

Thank you so much for this account, it's so detailed and I've always hoped for this...something different from what some quack historians have been saying here and still f**lishly bragging on (I'm not saying everything u dropped is accurate tho, just appreciate the fact that u could put up a logical story of the topic).

Now, u mentioned that they didn't meet anyone in the Island part but later.moved to badagry side where they met the Aworis

Another clarification I will like to get is, the war between them and the aworis, were they conquered by the Aworis?

Then, were they chased out of Island too, after the conquest,.if they had been conquered by the Aworis?

Thanks and God bless as your prompt response will be appreciated
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Raf4: 11:30am On Dec 07, 2023
Procashtips:


Again, tales by moonlight.

Post the evidence stating that Benin Kingdom conquered the Aworis which led to them pay tax to the former.

Is this too hard to do?

Which evidence do you want again? All the available history books of more than a century old recorded so. The only book that is saying otherwise is the one written by Ereduawa II less than 20yrs ago.
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Raf4: 11:32am On Dec 07, 2023
Thebadpolitican:


You sound pained, you need to cool off buddy

Dispute what I wrote up there na. No way, you can only resort to insult.
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Raf4: 11:36am On Dec 07, 2023
Thebadpolitican:


Or are you the one living in self deceit

An excavation was done for Godsake no bones
Were found in the site, my explanation in my writeup explains how it came about
. Am glad you have learned the truth
Tho you sound rebellious in your response but it's normal it will die out

Good luck

Which excavation done on a shrine?
The shrine is still intact in Ile-Ife till today. Have they done any excavation to confirm any of Bini obas buried in Bini apart from Akenzua II and Ereduawa II?
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Ghostagain: 11:48am On Dec 07, 2023
Beuberry:


Pic 1 Benin
Pic 2 Ife
Pic 3 Benin queen mother
Pic 4 Ife ancient queen image.
Look at the eyes o, the stylized eyes, beads, head etc.
Are you still blind to see the similarities, dear Uncle modern day Ologbosere?
When will you guys stop with the fraud.
The only artefact in there which is not a recent copy is the third one.
All the rest are recently made copies of Benin artefacts, they are not ancient at all.

Why didn't anybody call this out ?
Do you guys know anything about Benin Bronzes ?

When discussing history, Yoruba always come with fraud.
Why don't you guys just do like normal people and try to research history instead of rewriting it ?
Your Ife is not in any ancient map, that is to tell you it was either an irrelevant village, or it is a new settlement.

To my Edo folks, do not lower the bar of proof. That would be a gift to the Yoruba fraudsters. They are basically defending fairytales, so they can't substantiate them with logic and evidence. If you start lowering the requirements for proof, then you open the door for fraud and you give them a chance to defend their lie.
History is researched in eyewitness written documents!

Mr fraudster, the second picture is that if a recently made artefact depicting the Oba of Benin, it is not an "Ife artefact".

Let me help you:
Picture 1: recently made artefact depicting the Oba of Benin.
Picture 2: again recently made artefact of the Oba of Benin and a Benin noble
Picture 3: ancient Benin artefact.
Picture 4: bad recent copy of Benin artefacts.

1 Like

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Procashtips(m): 11:54am On Dec 07, 2023
Raf4:


Which evidence do you want again? All the available history books of more than a century old recorded so. The only book that is saying otherwise is the one written by Ereduawa II less than 20yrs ago.

Lol post the link to your so called evidence and stop beating around the bush.
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Ghostagain: 12:01pm On Dec 07, 2023
Raf4:


Which evidence do you want again? All the available history books of more than a century old recorded so. The only book that is saying otherwise is the one written by Ereduawa II less than 20yrs ago.
It is not about "history books", it is about documents written by eye-witnesses. All you are proving with the date of your "history books" is that Yoruba were already involved in rewriting history 100 years ago.
I posted documents much older than your "history books" and they contradicted your "history books". And the documents which I posted were written by people describing what their eyes were seeing contrary to your "history books" written by people talking about things they claimed happened hundreds of years before their grand parents were born.
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Ghostagain: 12:02pm On Dec 07, 2023
Procashtips:


Lol post the link to your so called evidence and stop beating around the bush.
Why did you guys just let the lie about the artefacts to go unchallenged?
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Procashtips(m): 12:04pm On Dec 07, 2023
Ghostagain:

Why did you guys just let the lie about the artefacts to go unchallenged?

I don't know how to jump about

He's yet to provide evidence to the lie he's sprewing, same person would not have answers to more complex lies his counterparts are spreading.
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Ghostagain: 12:06pm On Dec 07, 2023
Procashtips:


I don't know how to jump about

He's yet to provide evidence to the lie he's sprewing, same person would not have answers to more complex lies his counterparts are spreading.
He called a recently made artefact (depicting the Oba of Benin) an Ife ancient artefact 🤣
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Ghostagain: 12:09pm On Dec 07, 2023
Obi of Agbor in the 1930's. Notice that his regalia which he inherited from his ancestors is the same as that which is depicted in some artefacts. Those whom are assigning gender to artefacts are wrong. The crown of this noble Obi is the same as the one you see on the ancient Benin artefact which you called "Queen mother".

These artefacts depict Benin empire, they have nothing to do with Ife. All over Benin empire, the nobles have precolonial regalia's which are exactly what you can see in the artefacts.
Yoruba fraudsters who understand nothing about Benin culture should stop trying to rewrite Ife into Benin history. The claiming of Benin artefacts (and copies of of them) is a new low.
The dress code depicted in the artefacts is that of Benin empire, it is not that of Ife, at all. Every Obi has that regalia with the conical crown. Only the Oba has the crown which figures the Benin swords. Having such a regalia is s symbole of bring part of Benin empire.

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Raf4: 12:21pm On Dec 07, 2023
Ghostagain:

It is not about "history books", it is about documents written by eye-witnesses. All you are proving with the date of your "history books" is that Yoruba were already involved in rewriting history 100 years ago.
I posted documents much older than your "history books" and they contradicted your "history books". And the documents which I posted were written by people describing what their eyes were seeing contrary to your "history books" written by people talking about things they claimed happened hundreds of years before their grand parents were born.

So, who is the eye witness you're referring to here? And which documents?

Portuguese sailed ⛵️ into Ereko that they named Lagos in 1472, met Awori Yoruba there, established trading contacts with them and all these were well documented by them. After about 2 centuries later, your oba of Bini forcefully hijacked the control of the trading activities, installed a king on the parcel of land gifted him by Aromire and the 1st oba was installed around 1630s.
My question is how can you establish a place in 1630 when the place was already in existence and in communication with the outside world, Portuguese, as far back as 1472?

1 Like

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Omobude244: 12:27pm On Dec 07, 2023
Raf4:


Tell us the names of Obagodo's parents in igodomigodo or Bini land. Does the name Obagodo sound edoid to you?
lolz
so Obagodo fell from the sky
landed in ile ife and headed to benin grin grin

u be ozuor

Obagodo or Igodo was among the odionweres that made up the many autonomous communities/villages that agreed to come together and form a unified community for easy security, commerce and trade

Igodo was the most powerful then and he was chosen to lead to them. he rule very well and the kingship was left in his lineage.

can u tell me how he came from ife to benin?
i want to know

1 Like

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Ghostagain: 12:27pm On Dec 07, 2023
Raf4:


So, who is the eye witness you're referring to here? And which documents?

Portuguese sailed ⛵️ into Ereko that they named Lagos in 1472, met Awori Yoruba there, established trading contacts with them and all these were well documented by them. After about 2 centuries later, your oba of Bini forcefully hijacked the control of the trading activities, installed a king on the parcel of land gifted him by Aromire and the 1st oba was installed around 1630s.
My question is how can you establish a place in 1630 when the place was already in existence and in communication with the outside world, Portuguese, as far back as 1472?
You've just been caught claiming copies of Benin artefacts were actually Ife artefacts, yet you keep talking, do you have no shame ?

Did you even read the comment which you are replying ?
Are you asking me to reference eyewitnesses in my explanation of how history is researched? What sense does this make?

And you go on to write an other unsubstantiated story.
You just can't stop telling lies, it is stronger than you.

"all these were well documented by them", where are the documents? Fairytale peddler.
Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Ghostagain: 12:33pm On Dec 07, 2023
Picture 1: Obi Gbenoba of Agbor in the 1930's
Picture 2: Oni of Ife in the 1930's

Which one looks more noble ?

Also tell me, that Oni regalia, is it the common dress code between Benin and Ife which the yoruba fraudster is talking about ?

Re: Oldest History Books Say Yoruba Not Benin Founded Lagos by Raf4: 12:35pm On Dec 07, 2023
Ghostagain:

You've just been caught claiming copies of Benin artefacts were actually Ife artefacts, yet you keep talking, do you have no shame ?

Did you even read the comment which you are replying ?
Are you asking me to reference eyewitnesses in my explanation of how history is researched? What sense does this make?

And you go on to write an other unsubstantiated story.
You just can't stop telling lies, it is stronger than you.

"all these were well documented by them", where are the documents? Fairytale peddler.

1.Dispute the fact that the Portuguese sailed into Ereko/Eko/Lagos Island in 1472 and met Aworis/Yoruba there
2. Provide the date the 1st Oba of Ereko/Eko/Lagos was installed.
3. Now reconcile the events and prove how Bini founded Lagos or how Lagos belongs to Bini.

(1) (2) (3) ... (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (Reply)

Ooni Of Ife Speaks At School Of Oriental & African Studies,London(photos) / Photo: Wrestling Festival In Adamawa / Iru Kingdom: The End Of A Dominating Dynasty

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 99
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.